"Controlled
Chemical Deliveries"
Jailed former drug squad detective, Stephen
Paton (left) was a member of unit two of the drug
squad, the group assigned to investigate amphetamine syndicates.
While the rest of the squad struggled to deal
with heroin rings, unit two managed to arrest many of its top targets.
Their secret to success was a tactic known as
controlled chemical deliveries.
In short, the unit bought chemicals that could be
used to make amphetamines then, using a network of informers, sold them to
suspects to try to follow the trail to the labs and manufacturers.
In 1996 disgraced drug squad Detective-Sergaent
Wayne Strawhorn travelled overseas to study
international methods of amphetamine detection.
In Britain he was shown a secret police system of
buying drugs from chemical wholesalers and then selling them at black-market
prices as part of undercover sting operations.
Under the system of so-called "controlled
deliveries" undercover police or trusted informers would sell chemicals to
amphetamine producers and would then gather evidence for final prosecutions.
Strawhorn pushed for the system to be introduced
in Victoria and after some initial reluctance from his superiors, a trial
program was introduced.
It was a success and became the key method of
exposing major speed syndicates for the next five years.
The drug squad bought so much of the anti-cold
medication Sudafed, a drug that can be used in amphetamine production, it became
the manufacturer's biggest national client, and was eligible for discounts.
The money generated through Victoria Police's delivery program was vast:
pseudoephedrine purchased from a chemical company can be sold on the black
market at a 6000 per cent mark-up.
According to facts presented in court during
Wayne Strawhorn's trial, police were
able to purchase 1kg of pseudoephedrine for $170 and resell it to criminal gangs for
$10,000.
Because pseudo is so easily converted into speed, Victoria Police only
authorised one delivery of the drug in August 1998. But despite strict
guidelines governing the policy, by late 1999 the drug squad was out of
control and nobody above senior sergeant rank was monitoring the deliveries.
In his interim report into allegations of
corruption in the drug squad tabled in State Parliament in June 2003, Ombudsman
Barry Perry found the tactic to be fatally flawed.
"The practice of supplying informers with
chemicals without any significant controls may have resulted in the drug squad
creating an elite group of manufacturers and suppliers who may not have been so
involved had it not been for the opportunity provided by police."
Dr Perry said: "The scale and complexity of
many of the transactions uncovered is beyond belief.
The practice is one that has been examined in
depth, and largely rejected as an absolute last resort by the majority of law
enforcement agencies both in Australia and internationally."
Chief Commissioner Christine Nixon has now banned
police from using controlled chemical deliveries and replaced the drug squad
with the major drug investigation division.
According to Paton the system was out of control.
"It was not used as the last resort. It was
used as the first and only resort."
Dr Perry estimated the amount of chemicals lost
at 40 per cent to 80 per cent.
Paton says it was more like 90 per cent.
"We would try and follow a plastic bag
containing tablets or small bottles of liquid. It was ridiculous."
He says many of the sales were done with no
intention of arresting the suspects, and were simply fishing expeditions.
"They were non-evidentiary sales, or
intelligence-gathering exercises. It was a joke. We just kept losing the
shit."
Paton said 1000 boxes of Sudafed disappeared from
inside the drug squad office in St Kilda Road.
Under the controlled chemical delivery scheme
police were supposed to fill out paperwork and have their requests authorised by
senior police before any drugs could be purchased.
But Paton said the drug squad stockpiled
chemicals for use on authorised and unauthorised jobs.
He also said that informers were rewarded with
free chemicals.
But the real profiteers were the police
department.
Buying at wholesale and selling at blackmarket
prices meant the drug squad made money on nearly every deal.
According to Dr Perry, the drug squad chemical
purchase account stood at $267,137 in August 2001.
According to Paton, some of the profits from the
scheme had already been spent.
"It was diverted for heroin buys because
money for undercover jobs had been cut."
Senior police say that some of the undercover
budget had been used by the crime department to buy computers.
"They actively encouraged the chemical
diversion policy because it helped fund other areas in the drug squad,"
according to Paton.
According to a confidential interim Ceja report
corruption claims against the former drug squad were worse than first thought.
Detectives from the taskforce were looking at
allegations that some police had helped themselves to suspects' property in
their own version of asset seizure, grabbing pornographic material, wines,
mobile phones, casino chips and cash.
Taskforce investigators have also been told that
a disturbing number of young police are abusing drugs.
A police source told The Age that in one
case a group of suburban detectives drinking in an upmarket hotel rang a
constable at the local station who was a dealer. "He dropped some ecstasy
around to the pub that night."
In December 2000 a former detective working at
the Sigma chemical company raised concerns about the amount of chemicals bought
by the drug squad.
Paton said he was already set to resign - "I
decided that enough was enough."
Ceja investigators have gave evidence
that Paton was threatened, including having bullets sent to his home.
With his guilty plea Paton will receive a
discount on his sentence.
But he still has his doubts.
"Sometimes I think it would have been better
to shut up and just do the time. At least I wouldn't have to look over my
shoulder for the rest of my life and worry about my wife and kids."
Surprisingly, Paton would still like to work for
the police force he betrayed.
"I want to talk to young police after they
have been in the job for a year. I want to tell them of the consequences.
"I have had to remortgage my home to pay
legal bills. I have put my wife and children at risk. I have lost my job, my
future and my respect. It nearly cost me my marriage. I couldn't see what I was
doing was wrong.
"We were locking up crooks. You just forget
where the line is."
In December 2001, Chief Commissioner Christine
Nixon dumped the drug squad, replacing it with the major drug investigation
division.
She introduced about 150 reforms, scrapping the
drug diversion tactic and returning to a strict policy of limited tenure for
detectives.
Det-Sgt Strawhorn was an immediate casualty and was moved
against his will to the fraud squad.
He was later charged with drug trafficking and
jailed.