Underbelly: The Gangland War
The True Story Behind The Underbelly
TV Series
Underbelly - The Gangland
War, takes up where Leadbelly left off in 2004. If you like Channel 9's
new series, you'll love this book by John Silvester and Andrew Rule. Purchase from
auscrimebooks
Gatto, Melbourne's foremost
identity
linked to the underworld, was one of Victoria's top
boxers in the 1970s.
At one stage
Gatto, an
alleged standover man, was
an aspirant for the Australian heavyweight title.
He has admitted to his involvement in Melbourne's
illegal gambling scene in the 1980s and '90s.
Age reporter Nick McKenzie wrote the following:
"Gatto is
a master networker. When he attends the boxing as a spectator, the journey to
his seat is a long one, slowed by numerous handshakes. "
"His
network includes known crime figures as well as serving and former police
officers, lawyers, construction company owners, unionists and wealthy business
people."
"A senior detective is among a handful of public officials who have
attracted the attention of anti-corruption investigators because of an
association with Gatto."
"Others in Gatto's network help sustain his business empire — some
create a demand for Gatto's skills as an industrial relations mediator, despite
his lack of formal training."
"Gatto's dual reach into the underworld and into legitimate and
regulated sectors, say those aware of past attempts to investigate him, raises
key questions about the state's anti-crime and corruption system."
"If Gatto is a crime figure, why has he got away with it for so long and
what role, if any, have his contacts in the criminal justice system and
elsewhere played in helping him stay a step ahead of the law? If he is
legitimate, why, and at what cost, have multiple law enforcement agencies
directed their efforts against him?"
The relationships between Gatto and some public officials has caused concern.
Associations between some officers and the
"Carlton Crew" date to the '80s and '90s.
"The amount of old
detectives I saw having lunch almost daily with these people …" says a
former detective, who claims his efforts to shut down the crew's illegal gaming
rooms were thwarted by a senior policeman.
What separates Gatto from most other figures of
interest to authorities is his ability to juggle his association with those in
legitimate industries with those in the criminal world.
"He knows many of the biggest crooks in
Australia," says one former organised crime investigator.
Association, of course, is not a crime. So while
authorities question why any person would meet regularly with suspected and
known criminals, others stress Gatto's lack of criminal convictions.
"Once he gets targeted, they (the
authorities) never lay off. As far as I know, he is legitimate. But the police
would like to make him fail," a defence lawyer said.
Mr Gatto,
who listed his job as landscape gardener, has convictions for offences including
burglary, assaulting police, possessing firearms, and obtaining financial
advantage by deception.
He faced a committal hearing in
1997 on counts of extortion, blackmail and making threats to kill.
It was found he had no case to
answer on the charges, laid by the organised crime squad.
Gatto runs a company called Arbitrations and
Mediations Pty Ltd and has an interest in crane company,
Elite Cranes.
"I'm a negotiator and mediator, and I do a
good job at it," Gatto once told The Age.
The burly Mr Gatto
was a close associate of crime boss Alphonse
Gangitano, shot dead in January 1998.
In an
interview with the Age Gatto denied this.
"He was a friend, but they keep
tying me up with Alphonse.
Why don't they let him rest in peace?"
In September
1998, Gatto, then 42, publicly denied murdering leading underworld figure, Giuseppe
''Joe
Arena'', ten years before.
Gatto
said he was shocked at a news report he claims pointed the finger at him over
the 1988 slaying of Arena.
Mr
Arena,
known to some as "the friendly godfather", was shot dead in the
driveway of his Bayswater home in an apparent gangland execution.
Gatto said he
contacted the
Arena family after a newspaper report indicated he was prime suspect in the 1988
killing.
He said his father
was a good friend of Mr
Arena's
and he had also been an acquaintance of the dead man.
"I passed on my
respects (to the
Arena's)
and told them I knew nothing about it," he said. "They were quite
shocked to hear that my name had been mentioned."
He denied allegations he was a standover man who had been responsible for a
series of violent attacks in the past decade.
Mr Gatto's
lawyer, George
Defteros, said he had sought advice from a Queen's Counsel on finding out
the source of the murder allegations.
He said the
accusation of involvement in the
Arena murder had clearly been designed to cause his client mischief.
Claims he had an
"inappropriate relationship" with controversial bail justice Rowena
Allsop were dismissed by Gatto.
Ms Allsop was the
subject of a 1996 investigation by the Attorney-General into her friendship with
Alphonse
Gangitano.
"I'm sure that
the people who are raising their eyebrows are jealous they can't talk to people
on different levels."
The pair were
photographed at a Melbourne kick-boxing tournament.
Ms Allsop says she is a keen
kick-boxing fan.
She denied having
socialised with Mr Gatto, although said she had met him at
least twice since
Gangitano's
death.
On May 6, 2000, a
court heard a punting frenzy lost a gambler more than $300,000 in a day after he
placed nearly half a million dollars in bets using a false name.
Dominic
"Mick" Gatto, then 44 and of East Doncaster, faced
deception charges after allegedly placing 39 telephone bets with bookmaker
Rodney Cleary on June 12, 1999.
Mr Cleary told
Melbourne Magistrates' Court a long-standing and trusted client recommended Mr Gatto,
but said he was introduced as Mick Delgado.
Mr Cleary said he
became concerned when a cheque for $79,000 to partially cover Mr Gatto's
losses was stopped.
Soon after the
betting spree, a racecourse detective warned Mr Cleary to be careful of Mr Gatto.
But Mr Cleary told
the court he was unaware of Mr Gatto's identity.
When asked by
defence counsel Robert Richter, QC, his reaction after discovering Mr Gatto's
true identity, Mr Cleary said he was shocked.
Mr Cleary said he
expected to receive about 10 to 20 per cent of the money owed.
Mr Gatto
pleaded not guilty to 40 charges of obtaining financial advantage by deception.
Gatto was later
fined $10,000
Shortly later he was
charged and acquitted over allegedly driving a car into a man.
Since 2001, Gatto has drawn the attention of at
least four police investigations into his alleged illegal activities.
None has been able to sustain a conviction against
him.
Victoria Police's Operation Clarendon ranks as perhaps the least
impressive of the past inquiries into Gatto.
It was set up in 2002 by Chief Commissioner Christine Nixon to gain
intelligence on suspected ethnic-based crime groups in Melbourne, and Gatto was
among the figures targeted.
One of Clarendon's key investigators was now disgraced senior detective Wayne
Strawhorn. Providing informal advice was former barrister Kerry
Milte, who had previously represented several crime figures with Italian
heritage, including Gatto.
Milte was vouched for by a retired NSW police
officer, who apparently failed to relay doubts about Milte held by some in law
enforcement surrounding his reliability and fondness for a glass of wine.
Milte's method of gathering information included contacting police he was
friendly with and, sometimes under the guise of giving advice, figures in the
Italian community.
But his networking soon backfired.
Milte and several police
officers, including Steve Johnson and Norman Dunn, were later charged over
accessing sensitive police data without approval.
Strawhorn was suspended and charged over corruption in the former drug squad.
In the wash-up, a city lawyer whom Milte had approached via an intermediary was
lured to a restaurant and is believed to have been assaulted by figures close to
Gatto.
The reason for the assault remains unclear and the lawyer has never
complained to police. Sources say Clarendon suffered from poor management and
personnel selection, a finding likely to be reflected in a still-unreleased
report by the state's police watchdog, the Office of Police Integrity.
Operation Clarendon imploded.
On February 21,
2002, Gatto was subpoenaed to appear before the royal commission into the
building industry, over his role as a special "industrial relations"
consultant on Melbourne building sites.
Industry sources
said Mr Gatto was hired by a consultant to act as a mediator over the
development of a variety of industrial agreements at the National Gallery of
Victoria building site.
Mr Gatto's
solicitor, George Defteros, told The Age that his client would appear and
had "participated in the past in some negotiations and arbitrations in the
industry" but was unaware of the detail.
Australian Workers
Union national secretary Bill Shorten agreed that he had occasionally used
consultants but denied knowing Mr Gatto.
On February 25,
2002, The Age reported that the royal commission was investigating events
surrounding the payment of about $250,000 by a big contractor to a company that
solved awkward industrial relations problems.
The fee was
allegedly paid by construction giant Baulderstone Hornibrook to a subcontractor
working at the company's National Gallery of Victoria re-development site in
2000.
The subcontractor,
known as P.W and E.J Contracting Pty Ltd, subsequently enlisted the services
of Domenic "Mick" Gatto and David "the Rock" Hedgcock as so-
called "industrial trouble-shooters".
The stocky and unofficial king of
Melbourne's nightclub bouncers, Mr
Hedgcock, is a director of a company called Pro-Tect Securities, which
provides guards and crowd controllers to Melbourne's nightclub industry.
The former boxer has firearms,
theft and assault convictions.
He ran a gymnasium in the
city and went on to train awesome Melbourne boxer, Sammy Solimon.
Hedgcock was
known as a man to be reckoned with in Melbourne's rugged business underbelly.
He
received $189,750 in 2001 for helping to ensure industrial peace on a major city
project.
Building giant
Baulderstone Hornibrook was so worried about a potential industrial dispute at
its $95 million refurbishment of the National Gallery it was prepared to pay
$100,000 for peace.
But a company
executive lost his job when he made an unauthorised payment of almost three
times that sum to a small sub-contractor, P.W and E.J Contracting Pty Ltd, in
January 2001.
Commissioner Terence
Cole, QC, was told Mr Hedgcock and Mr Gatto operated in tandem solving
industrial relations problems in the industry.
In December 2000,
P.W and E.J Contracting's owner, Peter Barker, a convicted armed robber and,
like Gatto and Hedgecock, a former boxer, had approached them about problems at the
gallery site.
Mr Barker had been
authorised by Baulderstone to negotiate a site agreement with the Electrical
Trades Union.
The commission was
told the ETU's insistence that its preferred shop steward work on the site
threatened to scupper a crucial site agreement.
Baulderstone was
adamant the shop steward would not work on the site, blaming him for disruption
during construction of Colonial Stadium.
Mr Barker approached
Mr Hedgcock, whom he had known for 30 years, and Mr Gatto, who had done
industrial relations consulting for him.
The ETU signed the
site agreement after meetings between Mr Barker, Mr Gatto and ETU state
secretary Dean Mighell.
Mr Barker invoiced
Baulderstone for $250,000 plus GST -- more than twice what Baulderstone
executive Graham Milford-Cottam had been authorised to pay.
Baulderstone's
southern region director, Hedley Davis, told Mr Cottam he could not make the
payment.
"His response
was that we should pay it and . . . he expressed some concerns about his safety,
that people associated with this deal were the sorts of people that break
legs, were his words," Mr Davis said.
Mr Cottam was
dismissed after he made the payment anyway.
Counsel assisting
the royal commission, Dr James Renwick, said Mr Barker spent $79,500 on his home
loan and a new car for his son, while $189,750 was paid to a company controlled
by Mr Hedgcock.
Mr Hedgcock cashed a
cheque for $150,000 in $100 bills, which the commission's investigators have
been unable to trace.
Baulderstone may
have spent its $275,000 in vain.
By the middle of
2001, the oral agreement with the ETU had unravelled as the union
intensified industrial action to have another shop steward employed on the site.
That industrial
action only stopped after the steward began work.
Outside the
commission, Mr Gatto's and Mr Hedgcock's solicitor, George Defteros, said they
rejected any implication they had used threats or intimidation within the
industry.
He said his clients
would co-operate fully.
"They have
absolutely nothing to hide," Mr Defteros said.
Mr Mighell said he
hoped that the $250,000 payment by Baulderstone would be fully investigated.
On Wednesday
February 28, 2002, Mick Gatto, in an emotional outburst, claimed he was being
made a scapegoat by the inquiry and strenuously denied he was a standover man.
He said the
commission had damaged his reputation and caused his family enormous stress,
vowing to commissioner Terence Cole QC, "I will fight you all the
way, tooth and nail".
Mr Cole suggested Mr
Gatto "keep calm", and said that anyone who disrupted the commission
faced heavy fines and jail for up to three months.
After being asked
about money paid to his children Mr Gatto became agitated saying he had been
"branded" for a week.
"My mother is
hysterical, my children, their girlfriends and partners want to leave them. I
hope one day you're in this position....I'm not a standover man. I'm not a man
off ill repute. Fair enough I've got a chequered past....bit I paid
for...whatever I have done wrong.
"I don't
appreciate this nonsense that you are looking for someone to blame to justify
your existence here today., to justify 300 investigators and teams of lawyers.
You won't be justifying your existence with me. I promise you. I will fight you
all the way, tooth and nail.
In an interview
published in the Melbourne Age on March 2, 2002, Gatto furiously denied being a
standover man or "king of the underworld".
He said that he put
the accusations down to jealousy because he "dresses well" and
"drives a nice car", and he notes that he "mixes well" with
people throughout Australia.
Melbourne's Lord
Mayor, John So sent him a Christmas card last year for instance. "It's not
right that they seem to think I'm king of the underworld......all this nonsense
is not right for my family or my children", Mr Gatto said.
Gatto admitted to
being involved in controversy in the past but said that the publicity he was now
receiving was of a far greater magnitude," he said of accusations bought
against him the previous week.
"I shy away
from the spotlight and don't like to be in the public arena."
"Unfortunately
this time they (his accusers) have roped me into something they thought was a
bonanza. They were looking for a scapegoat, a guinea-pig, and they thought it
was going to be me and the union.
"Mate, I'll
join arm in arm with the union and fight them all the way. The people of the
union are beautiful people.
On October 23, 2002, colourful detective Dave
Waters was called before a
royal commission investigating police corruption in Western Australia to reveal
his association with some of the nation's most controversial figures.
They included Mick Gatto, alleged WA crime boss
John Kizon and notorious former NSW detective Roger
Rogerson.
Waters was asked
to explain to the royal commission on police corruption about his wide group of
friends.
At no stage did the commission suggest or allege
he had broken the law, but they were intrigued by his colourful associates.
In Perth, he was quizzed about a meeting he had
with the alleged crime boss and WA identity John Kizon
in a Perth hotel back in September 2001.
He responded that he went to Perth for the
funeral of CIB chief Don Hancock, who was killed in a car bombing, and was asked
to contact Kizon by Mick Gatto.
Among Kizon's claims
to fame is being one of the last people to speak to alleged Melbourne crime boss
Alphonse Gangitano on the phone before Gangitano
was murdered in his Templestowe home in January 1998.
Kizon was observed
by surveillance officers in the company of two West Coast Eagles players in
Melbourne during the 2001 grand final week.
Waters would later
chat on the phone with an AFL source about the players and allegations of drug
use.
Waters said Gatto told him as he left for the
Hancock funeral: "If you're over there, a bloke will take you out and buy
you a drink." The man was Kizon.
What Waters didn't
know was the WA commission had a secret camera in the Perth hotel where the two
men met.
While admitting he knew Gatto,
Waters told the WA commission they were neither
friends nor business associates.
Another investigation looking at Gatto was
under way in early 2003.
Operation Barrator was led by the nation's most powerful crime-fighting body,
the Australian Crime Commission.
According to the commission's 2003 annual report, Barrator targeted a network
operating "against a criminal backdrop of pervasiveness, resilience,
entrepreneurialism and corruption — all features which make it difficult for
law enforcement to effectively disrupt organised criminal activities".
This network allegedly included former NSW detective Roger
Rogerson, infamous Sydney identity Tom Domican (who had previously beaten
several murder charges), and alleged Perth crime boss John
Kizon.
Gatto, along with several of his close associates, allegedly made up the
Melbourne arm.
Former law enforcement figures say Barrator built an impressive intelligence
bank, some of which has dripped out in open court hearings.
An associate of Gatto's was observed making regular visits to restaurants in
Lygon Street, Carlton. It was suspected that he was picking up "protection
money" although, when asked by investigators, restaurant owners refused to
provide details. Debt collection and money lending at high interest rates also
proved profitable for Gatto and his associates — dubbed the "Carlton
Crew".
Operation Barrator charged Kizon with insider trading and an associate of
Gatto, Angelo Mario Venditti, with fraud. But
Gatto was never charged and Barrator gained no evidence to implicate him in one
of the operation's primary concerns, drug importation.
As Barrator wound down, Gatto emerged unscathed, except for the $300,000 tax
bill he faced after an assessment of his spending patterns put his undeclared
earnings at more than $2 million over three years. Despite the heat, business
was booming.
For several months in mid to late 2003, Gatto
and suspected hitman Andrew "Benji"
Veniamin were "buddy" and "mate" and "champ"
to each other, speaking on average every four or five days.
DECEMBER 12, 2003:
Gatto How are you, mate? . . . What’s going on, mate? Veniamin. . . Just
ringing in to say hello, see how you’re doing . .
But the late-night
shooting of Gatto's close friend, Graham
Kinniburgh outside his Kew home on December 13, 2003, drove the wedge of
suspicion between them.
Police said
that a tracking device showed that Veniaminwas not responsible for
Kinniburgh's murder but Gatto had come to blame Veniamin.
Gatto
was also warned by police that his own life was in danger.
Veniamin knew
he was under police surveillance and referred to it many times in his telephone
calls.
At one point he had said he might as well give
the police a CD of his conversations. He had been searched a number of times by
police.
The talk between the two was overheard through
police listening devices, which detected Veniamin's
mobile phone conversations.
The conversations showed the change in their
relationship, from one of friendship to one where Gatto was wary of Veniamin.
Several days after
Kinniburgh's murder, Gatto spoke to Veniamin
about arranging a meeting "to clear the air a bit". "Bring that
mate with you," he said.
On December 22, 2003, nine days after
Kinniburgh was killed, Gatto, accompanied by five others including Faruk
"Frank" Orman (an associate of Gatto and long-time friend of Veniamin),
met Veniamin and underworld companion Carl
Williams at Crown Casino.
Gatto's lawyer Robert Richter, QC would later say
that at the casino meeting, the message to Veniamin and
Carl Williams was that the underworld shootings were not Gatto's war.
The meeting lasted more than two hours. and was video-taped by the Casino's
security.
A court was later told that a lip-reader was able
to discern some of Gatto's statements, which included him telling Veniamin
and
Williams that they were "giving me
shit".
Detective Senior Constable Nigel L'Estrange, of
the Purana Taskforce, agreed that Gatto was observed to tell
Williams: "Anything with you, that's your problem. But if anything
comes my way then I'll send somebody to you... I'll be careful with you, be
careful with me. I believe you, you believe me, now we're even. That's a
warning."
Another one of Gatto's associates who appeared at
various times on the videotape was Steve Kaya.
Orman and
Kaya would both give evidence at Gatto's murder trial.
Veniamin
effectively passed his own death sentence.
FEBRUARY 1, 2004: Gatto
What’s going on, stranger? . . . have not heard of you. Veniamin
Been going out with my mate . . . Gatto . . . Everything going all right?
MARCH 19, 2004: Gatto You
givin’ me the arse? I have not heard from you for a month. Veniamin
I swear to you, mate, everybody I have rung on this phone has been raided. Gatto
I am not worried about being raided. I have got nothing to hide.
During the morning of March
23, 2004, Veniamin and Carl
Williams were sitting in the public gallery of the Melbourne Magistrates
Court.
They watched as a magistrate refused a police request for a DNA sample from
friend, Victor
"The Marathon Man" Brincat, over the murders of Jason
Moran and Pasquale Barbaro, shot dead outside a junior football clinic in
Essendon North on June 21, 2003.
With one exception, the same group of men who
had accompanied him to his Crown Casino meeting with Andrew Veniamin the
previous December was sitting with Gatto in La Porcella - which he effectively
used as his office - later that afternoon.
Gatto sipped coffee
with developers and businessmen, before shifting tables to sit with a convicted
drug trafficker, Geoffrey Graham Reading.
Also at the table were retired SP bookmaker Ron Bongetti, Hampton businessman
Steve Kaya, and Kaya's constant companion, Faruk Orman and, according to evidence tendered in
court, Brian Finn.
He later said he had retreated from his
friendship in the last 18 months of Veniamin's
life: "Like, he was always unpredictable, you know, but he just got a lot
worse".
Gatto had rung Veniamin, asking him to the
restaurant.
Veniamin left for the meeting, telling a
friend he was off to see "the big bloke".
Veniamin appeared at La Porcella
wearing white thongs, elastic-waisted three-quarter pants, a light T-shirt
and boxer shorts.
The restaurant was almost deserted, apart
from Gatto and his friends.
There was one customer drinking coffee at
an outdoor table.
After half an hour, Gatto led Veniamin
to a narrow passageway that ran off a storeroom from the restaurant's
kitchen.
About a metre wide, the passage's effective
width was only 66 centimetres since it was packed to head height on one
side with boxes.
Gatto shot Veniamin
twice to the neck and once
to the head.
He shot at him a fourth time as the
deceased lay dying on the floor of the passageway . . . but he missed.
In all, five shots were fired.
It was not clear in what order the shots
were fired, but two were necessarily fatal.
One passed through Veniamin's spinal column
and another went through his neck's carotid artery.
A third bullet entered his head and would
have rendered the deceased man incapable of purposeful action almost
immediately.
The shots, from a .38 calibre revolver,
were fired from close range and left powder burns on Veniamin's neck.
Despite the gunfire, no one went to see how
Veniamin was.
Gatto remained remarkably calm after the
shooting.
Emerging from the rear of the restaurant, Gatto
told proprietor Michael Choucair: "He tried to kill me. He said he wants to
kill me like he did to Graham."
He waited at the scene for police to arrive and
told them it was a clear
case of self-defence after Veniamin pulled out
a .38 and threatened to kill him.
Carl Williams
appeared at the scene some time after his friend had died.
Reporters attempted to question Williams
who ran off and locked himself in a toilet at a nearby service station before
being whisked away by a friend who arrived in a car.
Police said Gatto lured Veniamin
to the restaurant and shot
him in cold blood.
Gatto appeared in the Melbourne Magistrates'
Court the following morning after being charged with murder.
At the filing hearing, prosecutor Raeleene
Maxwell asked for Gatto's committal mention hearing to be heard on July 14.
He was not required to enter a plea.
A rare peek inside Gatto's world in the hours after he shot Veniamin dead was
revealed in a three-page letter he penned to fellow Carlton Crew elder Mario
Condello from his cell at Port Phillip Prison's high-security Charlotte Unit.
"I tell you what Mario, it's changed a lot since the days of old," he wrote of his treatment in jail after being arrested.
"I have to be honest, they treat you with the greatest of respect. I feel a bit like Hannibal Lecter."
Mr Gatto asked Condello to look after his personal affairs while he is behind bars and take care of his family.
"I am good as gold Mario, I can't believe what has happened to me the last couple of days, but so be it.
"I can't believe for a bloke that prides himself on not getting involved in all the bullshit, I can't believe how trouble finds me."
Mr Gatto told police immediately after the shooting that he was forced to shoot Veniamin when the younger man pulled a gun on him – a story he stuck to in his letter to
Condello.
"I can't believe that little maggot tried to kill me, anyway he is in his place," Mr Gatto wrote.
"Mario give the old bloke my regards and all our team – tell them I am going alright and I will be in touch in the near future.
"Keep your eyes wide opened, you can't trust any of these rats. I would hate to see anything happen to any of ours."
On June 30, 2004, the Herald Sun reported that Victorian Premier Steve Bracks had expressed discomfort at
attending an ALP fundraiser supported by a business half-owned by Mick Gatto.
"I wouldn't like those arrangements at all in the future," Mr Bracks said when
quizzed about the involvement of Elite Cranes at the $1000-a-head
dinner.
The dinner was organised by the state ALP's fundraising arm, Progressive
Business.
Elite Cranes had joined Progressive Business
about a month before, and invited construction union leaders to the June 24 dinner
with the Premier and Cabinet ministers.
Asked if he was comfortable with Elite Crane's presence at the dinner,
Mr Bracks said: "Absolutely not. Of course not.''
Agriculture Minister Bob Cameron, who sat on the same table as Elite Cranes
staff, said he had not spoken to Progressive Business about the matter.
"I go
to many functions, I meet all sorts of people and will continue to do so,'' he
said
Elite Cranes was owned jointly by Mr Gatto and the company's
secretary and sole director, Mathew Tomas (left) - listed as Matt Thomas on Australian
Securities and Investments Commission records.
Mr Tomas was one of three men acquitted of murdering a teenager who was
kicked and stomped to death in a crowded Carlton restaurant on July 16, 1996.
He was charged with the murder of Raymond Oueinati, 18, who was killed in a
savage attack at the Gatto Nero restaurant in Lygon St.
After Mr Tomas's acquittal in December 1998, lawyer
George Defteros expressed
his client's sympathy for the family of Mr Oueinati.
Mr Tomas told the Herald Sun he was an honest businessman who employed
about 30 people leasing mobile cranes.
While conceding he was a friend of Mr Gatto, Mr Tomas said he wanted nothing to
do with any illegal activity.
Jason Wood, a former detective who
went on to become an MP makes several recollections regarding T(h)omas on his
web-site.
"I recall in July 1996, while I
was a detective at the organised crime squad, a listening device affidavit being
prepared over several days. I recall the affidavit was near completion but still
needed to go through the rigorous tests of the special project unit."
"The target for this warrant
was Mat Thomas, who at the time was the driver for the now deceased Alphonse
Gangitano."
"Our
intention was to install a listening device in the car of Thomas but, because of
the high standard of proof required in the affidavit, more preparation time was
required."
"On
Sunday, July 14, 1996, a week after starting to compile the affidavit, Mat
Thomas drove his Mercedes Benz to the Gatto Nero Bar. When he left, Raymond
Oueinati was found dead, kicked to death."
"Thomas
was one of several suspects and was charged with the murder, but was
subsequently acquitted."
"Thomas
would say he was innocent. I say he was acquitted of murder."
"I
remember the Monday following the murder and the frustration faced by members of
the organised crime squad—knowing that, were the process for obtaining the
warrant made easier, what additional information would have been obtained and
supplied to the jury had police had a listening device installed in Thomas’s
car immediately after the death of Oueinati."
The Herald Sun later revealed
links between Tomas and long-serving police officer,
Tony Juric.
A secret anti-corruption taskforce
examining links between police, criminals and sex workers raided the
Australian Croatian Association as part of inquiries into Juric, its
president.
Officers from a joint Victoria Police and
Office of Police Integrity taskforce raided the club premises in
Footscray seizing documents and financial records.
The October2007 raids were the first overt move of a
long-running investigation into several police with suspected improper
associations, including some who have served at inner-city stations.
Mr Juric, who had been president of the
Croatian Social Club since 1995, was suspended from his role as uniform
sergeant at the St Kilda police station in October 2007.
Mr Juric's links with figures tied to the
crime world had caused concern among law enforcement officers.
In a speech at a Croatian community
function in 2006, Sergeant Juric thanked Mick Gatto, along with 19
other building industry figures, for providing free materials, labour
and equipment to renovate the Croatian association headquarters.
He also thanked Matt Tomas, who is a long-time friend of
Mr Juric, and also plays a prominent role in the Croatian community as
chairman of the Melbourne Knights Football Club, of which Sergeant Juric
is a former board member.
Elite Cranes, emerged from the ashes of a failed Sydney crane and
scaffolding company, TJF, which some builders joked stood for the acronym
"the job's f-----d".
TJF's Sydney-based industrial consultant was Tom Domican, one of the Australian Crime Commission's targets in Operation Barrator.
When TJF collapsed, owing ANZ Bank millions, its Melbourne manager, Tomas,
started Elite Cranes with his friend and business colleague, Gatto.
Tomas denied any role in TJF's woes, and
there is nothing to suggest he is anything but a legitimate businessman. Elite's
black mobile cranes continue to dot building sites across the state, including
projects by prominent building firm L.U. Simon.
Elite Cranes is active in the
community, offering sponsorship dollars and support to the Croatian Club in
Footscray and its sporting affiliate, the Melbourne Knights soccer club.
The
Croatian Club's president is Tony Juric, who by day is a sergeant at St Kilda
police station. Tomas, who has a Croatian background, chairs the Melbourne
Knights, the club for which he once starred as a player.
Mr Tomas said he had apologised to the Bracks Government for any
inconvenience.
"I now intend to focus on the activities of Elite Cranes and make sure we have
the most reputable crane company in Victoria,'' he said.
ASIC records show Mr Gatto's 150 shares in Elite
Cranes were transferred to Belgium Avenue Pty Ltd on June 28, 2004, after a failed bid
to move the shares in
Belgium Avenue is a $2 company owned by Primad Pty
Ltd.
Michael Di
Pietro, of Barkers Rd, Kew, is the sole director and secretary of
both companies and the owner of all Primad's 12 $1 shares.
Mr Di Pietro also owns a company called Gatto Holdings Pty Ltd.
Though there is no formal connection between this $1 company and Mr Gatto,
he owns two companies -- The Gatto Group Pty Ltd and La
Belle Resort Pty Ltd -- using the same Barkers Rd address with Mr Di Pietro.
ALP state secretary Eric Locke said he was unaware of the new part-owner, but if
Elite Cranes did not sever their ties with Mr Gatto, the ALP would cut its ties
with the company.
During Gatto's committal hearing on July 14,
2004, defence lawyer George
Defteros (left) asked Chief Magistrate Ian Gray if Mr Gatto could be moved to the
Melbourne Assessment Prison (MAP).
Mr Gatto wore runners with no shoelaces, a black
Fila tracksuit bottom with a white stripe on the side, and a cream and blue
ribbed tight long sleeved Billabong jumper.
At the hearing, Carl
Williams' wife, Roberta
Williams, waited outside the courtroom.
Accompanied by police, Ms Williams made an
emotional outburst toward the courtroom before leaving, leaning on her sister.
After the hearing, George
Defteros was asked if Mr Gatto would plead self-defence. Mr Defteros
said he had "no further comment at this stage," but added that he
anticipated Mr Gatto would make an application for bail at the Supreme Court
"in due course".
Gatto faced trial in May 2005 and admitted
shooting Veniamin twice in the neck and once in the head.
During the 14 months he was in jail awaiting his
trial, Gatto lost 30 kilos.
He insisted he was acting in self-defence after
Veniamin produced a gun and threatened to kill him.
Gatto said he thought he was a "dead
duck" as they struggled for the gun, with the first of five shots fired
narrowly missing his face.
The key question for the jury was which of the
two men carried the revolver into the restaurant.
"He actually kicked my foot under the table
and he motioned with his head like that, that he wanted to have a chat, and I
said 'Do you want to have a chat?' and he said 'Yes, I do.'
"I thought he led the way, but I'm not 100
per cent sure, and why I say that is I thought that we were going to go outside,
and actually he pointed into the kitchen and I said 'Wherever you want to go'.
And we walked in there.
"He walked in. I just followed him . . . he
turned around and he was just looking at me and he said 'I'm sick of hearing
this shit' and I said 'What do you mean?'
Gatto said Veniamin
had complained of hearing persistent rumours that Gatto blamed him for the
murder of Graham Kinniburgh.
Veniamin
claimed he would not interfere with him because Gatto was a mate.
"And at that point, I turned around and I
said 'Look, Andrew . . . I think it's better if you stay out of our company . .
. I really don't believe that you can be trusted. I'd just rather you not come
around near us at all'.
" . . . And I was looking at him in the eyes
and his face went all funny and he sort of stepped back and he said, he said,
'We had to kill Graham. We had to kill f---ing Graham.' He said 'F--- him and
f--- you' and he - I never seen where he got it from, but he pulled a gun out
and that's when I lunged . . . I just lunged at him and I grabbed his arm,
grabbed his arm with my hand, and the gun went off past my head.
Gatto, claimed he did not have time to reach into
his trouser pocket for his .25 calibre pistol which he had bought several years
earlier from Lewis Moran.
". . . I had hold of his hand with both my
hands and I sort of pushed it towards him and I - with my hands I sort of - I
forced - he had his hands on the trigger and I just forced his hands, squeezed
his hands to force him to pull the trigger and . . . I remember nearly falling
on the ground on top of him. He sort of pulled me over off balance.
". . . It was just bang bang, and I mean, I
don't know where it went or whatever. I've got to be honest, I thought I was a
dead duck anyway, I thought I was gone.
"And like I said, I remember nearly
stumbling, landing on top of him, and I just pulled the gun out of his hand
because he still had it in his hand. I pulled it out of the grip of his hand and
I ran out of the hallway there, out of the corridor into the restaurant."
Steve Kaya, an
associate of both Mick Gatto and Andrew Veniamin,
told the court of a time when Veniamin was trying to track down a rival named
Pasquale Zefina and that he was prepared to shoot Zefina's sister to "draw
him out".
Kaya said he talked
Veniamin out of carrying out the threat against the sister.
He said it was common knowledge that when Veniamin
ultimately found Zefina and shot him five times.
Veniaminhad also threatened to shoot police
at the St Kilda Road complex after a search of his mother's home uncovered a .38
revolver.
He told Kaya that
police had stolen some of his mother's jewellery.
"He said he was just going to run into the
police complex and do his best . .. . kill whoever he can kill," Kaya
said.
"I just talked him out of it. I calmed him
down."
Kaya also said
that a man - Brian Finn - who claimed Gatto handed him a pistol after the
shooting, was present the day Veniamin was killed.
He did not, however, see Finn after the shooting.
Mr Kaya (pictured
below with Mick Gatto) agreed that he had not mentioned Mr Finn being present in
an earlier statement.
After seven weeks of trial, eight hours
deliberation and 14 months in custody, Gatto was acquitted on June 15, 2005,
the jury accepting that the killing was in self-defence.
The trial ended in cheers, applause and squeals
of delight when the Supreme Court jury acquitted the Carlton identity.
Several jurors appeared distressed and shed tears
after bringing in the not guilty verdict.
Police denied that the verdict was a setback for
the Purana gangland taskforce, but it will mean an overhaul at the city mortuary
after it was revealed that key items of evidence may have been contaminated
there.
Gatto entered the court under guard and blowing a
kiss to a supporter in the public gallery.
He left the building to be embraced by his wife
Cheryl, and calling out "Thank God for the jury system".
But his acquittal may not have been the end of his
troubles with the law.
He faced being investigated over allegations
of perjury arising from evidence he gave during the trial, which appeared to
contradict sworn testimony he gave to the Australian Crime Commission in 2003.
Gatto's solicitor, Brian Rolfe, said the
prosecution case had been based on a theory, not facts, and that Gatto had
insisted throughout that he acted in self-defence.
"The prosecution could
never establish that Veniamin did not bring
the gun to the restaurant," Mr Rolfe said.
He said Gatto's defence, led by Robert Richter,
QC, had cost "many hundreds of thousands of dollars", including the
cost of independent forensic advice.
Prosecutor Geoff Horgan, SC, paid tribute to the
police investigators.
He said they had done an excellent job.
A police spokesman said the Purana taskforce was
continuing its work.
"The jury made its decision and we accept that,"
the spokesman said.
Senior barristers said the case was unique among
underworld killings because it was the only one in which the accused had stayed
at the scene to wait for police.
Darren Palmer, the criminology co-ordinator at
Deakin University, said the self-defence case mounted by Gatto was different
from most other cases in Melbourne's so-called underworld war.
"It does stand out as a very different case
to the others which we expect to come, because of that issue of (sole)
self-defence," Dr Palmer said. "I would not think it has much bearing
for Purana."
In other developments, the mortuary was to review
its procedures after the Gatto trial heard that key exhibits may have been
contaminated, and that there was a failure to note crucial details when
Veniamin's body was prepared for autopsy.
No record was made of whether the drawstring on Veniamin's track pants was tied, which could have indicated if he was capable of
securing a revolver at his waist when he arrived at the restaurant for his
fateful meeting with Gatto.
Also, gunshot residue found on Veniamin's
underwear could indicate a gun was carried in the waistband, but the findings
were compromised because the residue might have been transferred from his outer
garments to his underclothing when his body was undressed.
Jodie Leditschke, manager of forensic technical
services at the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine, confirmed that a
review of procedures was imminent.
"There are definitely some issues,"
she said.
Gatto marked his first full day of freedom
with a visit to the Lonsdale Street chambers of Robert Richter, QC, before
having lunch with friends at one of his old haunts in Lygon Street.
He was within a block or so of the restaurant
where he shot and killed Veniamin.
On June 25, 2005, the Age reported that Gatto
was making the media an offer he thought was too good to refuse - an exclusive
chat for a substantial price.
He had received a number of requests to tell his
story.
But as some associates of Mr Gatto had learned,
there is no such thing as a free lunch and he decided to auction the rights to
the exclusive interview - with the money to be donated to the Royal Children's
Hospital.
Mr Gatto had been a regular contributor to the
hospital and donated $5000 from his prison cell while on remand waiting for his
trial over the Veniamin killing.
"I have been doing it for the last 15
years," he said.
For many years, large amounts of money had been
raised for the hospital through an illegal two-up school in Melbourne, Mr Gatto
said.
Television, newspaper, radio and magazine
journalists joined the queue once occupied by police, prosecutors and the
Australian Crime Commission of those who have tried to persuade Mr Gatto to talk
about his life and the events that led to Veniamin's death.
It is believed that one television group has made
a bid of $50,000 for an exclusive interview.
"If people think I have something
interesting to say, then perhaps they will prepared to make a donation to a
worthy cause," Mr Gatto said.
"If not, then that's fine too, I'll just
get on with my life. It would get the media off my back and at the same time
raise money for the hospital."
Hospital spokeswoman Julie Webber told The
Age: "Mr Gatto is a long-time supporter of the Good Friday Appeal and
his donations have always been appreciated.
"We certainly have no objections in
accepting the money. We are not here to judge people."
"Mr Gatto said he was not interested in courting
publicity or making money from the media but was happy to talk if the price was
right."
On
October 21, 2005, the Herald Sun reported that Mick Gatto had bought a palatial
$2 million mansion in Melbourne's northeastern suburbs.
The French provincial-style
property sits on 4000sq m of landscaped grounds and boasts five bedrooms, five
bathrooms, a four-car garage, a pool, spa and tennis court.
It was believed Mr Gatto and his
wife Cheryle had been seen at the Lower Plenty property, which overlooks the
15th tee at Heidelberg Golf Club, several times in recent weeks.
They bought the Roseburn Court
home on September 28 but the deal had not been settled.
The price tag was just over $2
million and the sale was finalised without the property being subject to
finance.
A real estate advertisement for
the property describes it as the "ultimate family lifestyle combining
contemporary luxury with thoughtful and practical design''.
The Gattos' plans were still
believed to include spending time in Noosa, given that his crane company plans
to expand to the Sunshine Coast.
But a source told the Herald Sun
the Lower Plenty property was more of a family home than an investment property.
"You don't buy that kind of
house to move permanently to Queensland,'' the source said.
Mr Gatto's East Doncaster home
was expected to fetch more than $600,000.
In the early evening of February 6, 2006 Mario Condello joined friends, including
good friend and fellow Carlton Crew elder, Mick Gatto, at the Society Restaurant in Bourke St.
Condello
was last seen alive at 9.40pm when he left a restaurant in Hardware Lane in
the city to drive home after dining with a lawyer.
Condello,
52, was gunned down at his heavily secured home in North Road, Brighton East,
where he had returned to live.
He arrived there just on 10pm under the conditions of his bail.
When Condello believed he was at risk, he moved house.
But on this night, he drove into his driveway, opened the garage door and was
shot dead before it closed.
His killer is thought to have run into the garage when Condello
activated the
electronic door, fired at least three shots and fled before the door finished
closing.
The Herald Sun reported that a terrified woman was a telephone witness to the
murder.
The woman, a friend of Condello, heard him shot while she was talking to him on
the phone.
The secret witness was interviewed by police who hoped she may have heard the
voice of Condello's killer.
She refused to comment when approached by the Herald Sun and said she knew
nothing that could help police.
The woman is believed to have driven to the scene after hearing shots, but left
when she saw police at the house.
A Victoria Police spokeswoman confirmed the woman had been interviewed and that
investigations were continuing.
Eighteen months after police foiled a plot to kill Condello, police said they
had no information there would be another attempt.
Mick Gatto went to the Condello house shortly after his friend had been killed,
and police were concerned he may also be at risk.
Assistant Commissioner Simon Overland said, "The events of last night indicate to us that there may be,
and I say may, be some heightened risk to
Mick Gatto.
We have spoken to Mr Gatto already. We've made arrangements to speak to him
again, and we will be making offers of assistance and protection to him.
I have to say, though, our experience in the past is when we make these offers
they're not accepted.
When police spoke to Gatto he told them he had no idea who killed Condello.
"I know nothing about it. I don't believe it is gangland connected … no
way. I believe whatever the reason, it will come out in the wash."
Police suspect the man who ordered Condello's murder set a deadline on the hit
that was due to expire within weeks.
Condello's
trial for incitement to murder was to begin the next day with legal
argument, before the empanelling of a jury, and was expected to finish within
two weeks.
Condello
was charged with incitement to murder three men - one, a prominent
figure in Melbourne's gangland wars.
Gatto at Condello's funeral
Condello
was carried to his rest in a two-toned, golden bronze casket as bells
tolled.
Priests pleaded with a congregation not to exact vengeance for a
murdered man.
In
June 2006 Mick Gatto was back in court.
This time, he was a witness in a wrongful
dismissal case and made a two-day cameo appearance in the Supreme Court.
Ted Sent (right) had been the head of the huge
retirement village developer Primelife Corporation until he was sacked in 2000
from the $850,000-a-year job running the firm he had originally founded.
In the wrongful dismissal case, it was revealed
that sent had paid Gatto a monthly retainer to be his 'eyes and ears' in the
hope of encouraging industrial harmony on the company's building sites.
The payments began at $4,400 a month and rose to
$6,600.
Mick pocketed $220,000 over three years from the
grateful Sent.
The money was paid over during a monthly lunch at
Gatto's favourite haunt, La Porcella in Carlton.
During cross-examination Gatto revealed he had
been hit with a back tax bill of $1 million but had settled the bill for
$200,000.
It was revealed that during the lunches Sent
would slip over and hand the cash filled envelope to Mick.
The invitation usually began with a quick call
where Gatto would simply say: "It's that time of the month mate."
"We'd sort of have something to eat,"
Gatto recalled, "There would be a big group of us there and then he (Sent)
would call me aside and we would have a little chat in relation top building
issues or things that were troubling him at the sites or whatever.
"
"He would just pull
it out of his pocket and say, 'Here', and I would give him the invoice,"
Gatto said.
"He would also do it
in private; he'd never do it in front of anyone else."
On
June 9, 2006, the Herald Sun reported that police
were told Mick Gatto threatened to kill union boss
Dean Mighell in a building industry dispute.
Mr
Mighell confirmed having a dispute with Mr Gatto,
but denied being intimidated in any way.
"Mick
Gatto never threatened to kill me,'' he said.
Former
chief superintendent Kerry
Milte made the
death-threat claim in a five-hour taped interview
with detectives from Victoria Police's ethical
standards department.
Milte,
also a barrister, had once represented Gatto.
In
the interview Mr Milte also named allegedly corrupt
police and identified several organised crime
figures.
The
Herald Sun had seen a copy of the transcript of Mr
Milte's interview with ESD.
Mr
Milte, 61, a former Commonwealth police officer and
barrister, was recruited by Chief Commissioner
Christine Nixon in 2002 to help tackle organised
crime in Victoria.
He
has been committed to stand trial on charges
including bribery and conspiring with a Victorian
police officer to disclose confidential information.
In
his interview, Mr Milte:
NAMED
an Italian organised crime boss who was allegedly
involved in five murders.
CLAIMED
murdered mafia financier Mario Condello and another
underworld figure stripped a solicitor naked and
beat him in a Lygon St restaurant basement as a
warning not to speak about their activities.
IDENTIFIED
a Lygon St crime figure who had allegedly paid $4
million in bribes to senior Victorian police.
CLAIMED
corrupt police "green-lighted'' the illegal
activities of several Italian organised crime
bosses.
ALLEGED
the Italian syndicate has put gang members in
positions of authority in immigration, customs and
the police. Mr Milte told ESD why he was recruited
by Ms Nixon.
"Because
of some old connections, I had the means of getting
information on particularly Italian organised
crime,'' his August 19, 2005, record of interview
claimed.
"And
to a lesser degree, Chinese operations and to
another degree, some Lebanese people and that
principally involved Mick Gatto, Mario
Condello, Mokbel (fugitive crime boss Tony
Mokbel).''
Mr
Milte claimed in the interview that Mr Gatto had
threatened to kill Electrical Trades Union boss Dean
Mighell.
"He
came to see me via a politician,'' his record of
interview claimed. "I offered, in regard to the
obvious state of fear he was in, to make contact
between him and the police.''
Mr
Mighell denied Mr Milte's claim.
He
said a dispute with Mr Gatto over building work at
the National Gallery had been sorted out amicably.
Mr
Milte told the Herald Sun he was horrified his ESD
record of interview was being circulated.
He
claimed a small faction of Victorian police was
trying to undermine Ms Nixon and suggested
circulating his ESD interview was an attempt by
these officers to discredit her.
Mr
Milte would not identify Mr Mighell as the person
allegedly subjected to death threats, but said:
"The union official was in genuine fear of his
life.''
Mr
Milte told ESD about an alleged attack by Condello
and another man on a solicitor for an Italian
organised crime boss.
"They
stripped the solicitor naked . . . held a pistol to
his head, broke a plate on his head and wanted to
know how much he'd told me about what was going
on,'' he said.
On June 28, 2006, the Age reported that St Kilda sergeant
Chris
Lim was being investigated
by Victoria Police's ethical standards department over his interests in a
property company.
A fellow investor was an associate of Mick
Gatto.
Michael "Eyes" Pastras, 36, was shot
once in the buttocks and once in the thigh at a house in Albion St, Brunswick on
October 14, 2006.
A police statement said he was in a stable
condition.
The Herald Sun was told Mr Pastras
wouldn't
co-operate with police and refused to make a complaint about the shooting.
Detectives from the armed offenders taskforce
Emerald investigated.
Police said no motive had been established.
A police source said there was no evidence to
suggest the shooting was connected to Mr Pastras
implicating Andrew
Veniamin in wanting to kill Mr Gatto.
"But Veniamin's
associates know about it and would not be happy," the source said.
"It's a line of inquiry which will have to
be followed."
Pastras gave evidence at Mick Gatto's murder
trial that he spoke to Veniamin on March 23,
2004, the day Veniamin was shot dead by Mr Gatto.
He said that Veniamin
never mentioned anything to him about wanting to harm Mr Gatto.
But after testifying, he approached the Purana
gangland killing taskforce and made a statement refuting what he said in the
witness box.
Pastras told Purana detectives he saw Veniamin
with a gun when he went to meet Mr Gatto in Carlton's La Porcella restaurant and
that Veniamin told him he wanted Mr Gatto
dead.
He claimed Veniamin
told him: "I am f---ing dirty on Mick Gatto. He has got to go."
That evidence was not presented to the jury in
the Gatto murder trial.
Pastras was given the nickname Eyes after two
gangland figures gave him a $25,000 pair of diamond-studded glasses.
Pastras was named in a confidential Victoria
Police document that was blamed for prompting the executions of police informer Terrence
Hodson and his wife, Christine in 2004.
It contained details of what Hodson
told police and was leaked to Melbourne's underworld shortly before the Hodsons
were shot dead in their Kew home in 2004.
Early in 2007 Victoria Police hinted that they remained interested in
Gatto's activities.
"He's got all sorts of interesting associates and all sorts of
interesting connections," said Deputy Commissioner Simon Overland.
On
February
28, 2007,
Carl Williams
(left) appeared in the Supreme Court and
pleaded guilty to the murder of three rivals.
Williams
three times uttered the words "I plead guilty" to the charges
of murdering Lewis Moran, his son Jason
Moran and another man whose burnt remains were found in a wheelie
bin, but a court order bans publication of the victim's identity.
Williams had made an agreement to plead guilty
after several of his associates rolled over and gave evidence against him.
A guilty plea would give Williams
some hope of one day being released from jail.
Before Williams
would
agree to any deal he wanted to pass a message to a man
on the outside.
He desperately wanted him to know that
no matter what, he wished him no harm.
That man was Mick Gatto.
On
March
6, 2007, the Age reported that a former Victorian detective had quit his job as a senior Tax
Office investigator after an inquiry was launched into his links
with Mick Gatto.
The Australian Tax Office suspended
Peter Spence
(pictured left in 1988 with weapons seized from a raid in
Doncaster) who resigned in February after Victoria Police's Purana taskforce passed on information
about his relationship with Mr Gatto.
A senior police source said Mr Spence had an "an
inappropriate relationship" with the senior "Carlton
Crew" member and industrial relations consultant.
But Mr Spence told The Age he had done nothing wrong
and that he resigned a fortnight ago because the Tax Office was
unfairly targeting him after four years of dedicated service.
He said Mr Gatto was a contact he had known for more than 22
years through his former police work, including as a detective
with the now-disbanded major crime squad.
"Because I knew him and because I had been seen talking
to him, that was deemed to be sufficient to launch a
disciplinary action against me for a perceived conflict of
interest," Mr Spence said.
"I resigned because I could see that I was being
railroaded … If I had have been working on tax matters
relating directly to Mick Gatto or his associates, friends, or
family, yes, I could well understand it. But I wasn't."
As a serious non-compliance investigator, Mr Spence worked on
high-level investigations into organised and criminal tax fraud.
An ATO spokeswoman said she could not comment on why Mr
Spence was suspended as investigations were continuing.
She refused to comment on what vetting procedures were in
place to screen ATO investigators or what steps were taken to
protect investigation methodology.
Mr Gatto has been investigated by tax officials for failing to
declare more than $2 million of income.
In 2004, Mr Gatto paid $250,000 to the ATO to settle a
dispute over unpaid taxes.
Mr Spence said he never discussed sensitive tax or police
matters with Mr Gatto during their "three or four"
chance meetings in the past two years.
He said that in 2004 he arranged to meet the underworld
figure to pass on information about a threat to Mr Gatto's life.
"I became aware … that there was an offer of $150,000
to have him placed somewhere. In other words, to set up a
meeting with him (where he would be killed)," Mr Spence
said.
He denied it was inappropriate for an ATO investigator and
former detective to meet with Mr Gatto instead of passing such
information on to police and allowing them to relay it.
"If I heard someone was going to kill you, wouldn't I
tell you?" he asked The Age.
Mr Spence said that when he was subpoenaed by Mr Gatto's
defence team to give evidence about the threat in 2005, he
immediately told the ATO.
"I openly declared to the ATO that one, I was
subpoenaed, and two, that I did know Mick Gatto and had known
him for some time. And they didn't have a problem with that.
They in fact acknowledged that I had been open and
transparent," he said.
Mr Spence, whose evidence was not used in court, said he had
no regrets about maintaining contact with Mr Gatto.
"I like to know what is happening," he said.
"There are still elements in the underworld that don't like
me and I like to be able to at least protect my own situation
… if there is some sort of rumour that (someone) is out to get
me, which has happened in the past … at least I might hear
about it."
Last week, Deputy Commissioner Simon Overland said of Mr Gatto: "Well, he's got all sorts of interesting associates
and all sorts of interesting connections and I'm sure … he
would tell you that he is a law-abiding citizen. That may be the
case, but I guess I'm a little sceptical."
Mr Spence worked in the homicide squad and as a senior
sergeant in the major crime squad before leaving the force in
1996. He was transferred out of the major crime squad in the
early 1990s when force command pursued concerns about its
management and behaviour. The squad was later disbanded.
The resignation of Mr Spence came as Victoria Police steps
up co-operation with the ATO to fight organised crime.
Increasing numbers of ATO investigators are being seconded to
police taskforces targeting organised crime, with police intent
on crushing the financial base of suspects.
In an interview with Adam
Shand on Channel 9's Sunday program (aired on March 18,
2007), Mark
"Chopper" Read said that "the Italians"
were the real winners in Melbourne's gangland wars.
Read
said that Carl
Williams may have the score on the board, but
ultimately he is the loser.
Read named the real winner of the so-called
gangland war as Mick
Gatto.
"Mick Gatto's got more brains (than
Williams)," Read said.
"He was sitting there playing chess
quietly."
Read says Gatto used
Italian criminal philosophy, which in such
situations is usually superior to the
Australian version.
"Italians are prepared to lose 20 or 30
people in a gangland war in order to
ultimately win it," he said.
"Whereas Australians ... when in doubt,
shoot everybody."
Read also criticised Williams' choice of
hitmen.
"He (Williams) must be in his cell now
wondering what possessed him to hire these
knuckleheads, these junkies, these dogs and
these scumbags to go and do these killings
for him," he said.
"Now they're dobbing each other in,
whereas the Italians have stuck staunch and
haven't said a word."
A witness, known only as "C" who has been jailed for the crime, said in a statement that Goussis shot Moran and that another man, who is now terminally ill, shot
Wrout.
Goussis, one of five gangland figures to have been charged over the shooting, pleaded not guilty to murdering Moran and was discharged on a count of attempting to murder
Wrout.
Witness C, who cannot be identified for legal reasons, appeared in the Melbourne Magistrates' Court via video-link during
Goussis' two-day committal hearing.
The witness, a gangland double murderer, told the court that "bad blood" between he and Lewis Moran had contributed to the killing.
He said that he phoned Moran to ask "if he had a problem with me" before being told to "fuck off" and that after the brief conversation his mind was made up and he decided to accept a contract to kill him.
Mokbel wanted Moran dead because the crime group known as the 'Carlton Crew', of which Moran was a member, had bashed him in late 2002, witness C said in his police statement.
Stephen Sherrifs SC, for Goussis, called witness C a liar who had given several versions of his story to police.
When Mr Sherrifs asked the witness to recall the events leading up to the execution of Moran he said that he had spoken to Carl Williams who phoned him shortly before the shooting of Williams' right hand man
Andrew Veniamin on March 3, 2004.
Witness C said that a meeting then took place between himself, Williams, Mokbel and Goussis in the car park of Bridie O'Reilly's Hotel in Brunswick.
He said Williams asked him if he knew anyone interested in killing Moran and that the hit was worth $150,000.
Witness C said that Williams had asked him if there was any friction between he and the 'Carlton Crew'.
He said that he told Williams he had been dirty on some members of the crime group particularly Lewis Moran but especially
Jason Moran.
Witness C said he felt this way as a result of the 1998 murder of Lygon St crime boss and Carlton Crew leader,
Alphonse Gangitano for which many believed Jason Moran to have been responsible.
Witness C also said that he had been told that members of the Carlton Crew had put out a contract on his life and he had decided to phone Lewis Moran for some verification.
He said that Moran was less than forthcoming and launched into an expletive laden verbal tirade.
Witness C also told police that standover man Nik "The Russian" Radev had accepted a contract to kill Mick
Gatto.
However, Radev was shot dead before he could carry it out.
Witness C said in a statement that Mr Gatto had taken offence that he didn't inform him sooner of a rumour that
Radev had agreed to kill the former boxer.
"Because of this situation I was deemed to be an enemy of Mick and his friends. In my heart I was never his enemy," the hired killer said.
He said that he requested another meeting with Williams shortly after Andrew Veniamin was murdered because he was worried that there would be surveillance on underworld identities and that the contract may have been jeopardised.
Witness C said he and Goussis then met Williams and Mokbel at the Grove Cafe in Brunswick where they were assured that it was safe to go ahead with the murder.
Witness C said that a week after Moran's death, Williams rang and told him: "Good one, mate. You have 150,000 reasons to smile."
He later met Mokbel and was handed $140,000 in an envelope from the boot of the millionaire's car and told there was "more business there if you want it".
The missing $10,000 was never paid.
On
May 12, 2007, the Herald Sun reported that Gatto
had hit out at claims he was behind the murder of Mario Condello.
Gatto's angry denial
came as the Herald Sun revealed for the first time a letter Mr Gatto wrote to Condello from his prison cell just hours after shooting dead
Andrew Veniamin.
Police sources had recently told the Herald Sun Mr Gatto had not been ruled out as being behind the shooting murder of the former solicitor.
But Mr Gatto said the idea that he could be a suspect in the death was ridiculous.
"It is complete and utter rubbish. I loved the bloke," Mr Gatto said.
"I wish they would just leave me alone."
One theory being investigated is that Condello may have been eliminated by his own Carlton Crew associates.
Detectives have sought to question the brother of fugitive crime boss Tony Mokbel over the alternative theory that rival gangland bosses were behind the killing.
They have been refused permission by a magistrate.
Mr Gatto was in Brunswick at the time of Condello's death.
Condello, a father of three, was also godfather to one of Mr Gatto's sons.
On
May 29, 2007, the Herald Sun reported that Gatto had tipped his hat to Melbourne silk Peter Hayes, who was cremated
the day before.
Mr Gatto, who shared a glass of red with Mr Hayes in a Melbourne restaurant days before the silk's mysterious collapse, described the QC as an "absolute gentleman".
"Your support in hard times has not gone forgotten," Mr Gatto wrote in a Herald Sun death notice.
Mr Hayes was cremated in a private service yesterday.
He died in hospital on May 21, 10 days after he was found naked and unconscious in his Adelaide hotel room.
The leading Victorian bar member had been in Adelaide to represent ex-bikie client Tony Sobey.
A 28-year-old woman who had been with Mr Hayes before his collapse has been charged with administering a drug of dependence to him.
Mr Hayes' family -- who have appealed for privacy -- described him as their "lovable eccentric".
On
May 31, 2007, the Age reported that Gatto's nephew was being investigated by Victoria Police over an alleged
brawl in a city nightclub said to have resulted in injuries to two
police officers.
A fight involving more than a dozen
patrons, including 24-year-old Daniel Gatto, is alleged to have
taken place in the Balcony nightclub about 3am the previous Sunday
(May 26).
More than 20 police were called to
the Queen Street venue and used capsicum spray to quell the
violence, which spilled on to the street.
A witness claimed Mr Gatto
spat blood at one police officer and assaulted another.
A police spokesman said the Melbourne
criminal investigation unit was investigating, but no charges had
been laid.
Mr Gatto and a group of men are
believed to have been involved in another altercation with security
staff at King Street strip club Showgirls Bar 20 earlier in the
night.
John Gatto has defended his
24-year-old son, saying police beat him.
"This will be going to the
Ethical Standards Department because I want to press charges against
the police," he said.
"My son is badly hurt, they
broke his nose, they cracked his head open, he's got bruises all
over his body where he was kicked while handcuffed."
Melbourne East Inspector Chris Duthie
said the nightclub area around Queen and Little Collins streets had
become a trouble spot for police, who had attended a separate brawl
the same night. With "huge barns" licensed for hundreds of
people, "eventually you get conflict".
On
August 19, 2007, the Sunday Age reported
that famed corruption buster Tony Fitzgerald, QC,
was
heading a probe into the Melbourne arm of the
Australian Tax Office after concerns over links
between one of its senior investigators and Mick
Gatto.
Mr Fitzgerald's appointment late in July came after the resignation in February of senior tax
investigator and former Victoria Police detective
Peter Spence, who was earlier suspended due to his
association with Gatto.
It is the second time in three years that Mr
Fitzgerald has been called to Victoria to inquire
into the activities of local law enforcement
officers, sparking a fresh attack from Opposition
Leader Ted Baillieu on Victoria's "piecemeal
approach" to tackling corruption.
An email sent to staff three weeks before by ATO
deputy commissioner Michael Monaghan stated that Mr
Fitzgerald was investigating a serious
"potential conflict of interest in the serious
non-compliance" unit in Melbourne, where Mr
Spence formerly worked.
"While the commissioner is satisfied that
there is no evidence of any systemic issues in SNC,
the review will assure the highest levels of
integrity within the Tax Office," the email
says.
Mr Fitzgerald will question more than 40 ATO
staff members about investigation practices and
potential integrity issues highlighted by the Spence
case.
In another email, staff are advised that
information they provide Mr Fitzgerald will
"not be disclosed to third parties, provided
(it) does not involve your own misconduct".
Law enforcement sources said the ATO had
previously failed to deal with malfeasance or
suspected corruption, or properly address the risks
associated with its expanding role in fighting
organised crime and sophisticated tax fraud.
It is believed the Victoria Police privately
pressured the ATO to ensure it acted decisively
against Mr Spence, who has denied any wrongdoing and
claimed his infrequent association with Gatto was
not a conflict of interest.
ATO officials have investigated Gatto's earnings
as part of police probes into his business
activities, forcing him to repay
hundreds of thousands of dollars in unpaid tax.
The Sunday Age believes that Mr Fitzgerald
has been provided with a small number of complaints
lodged previously by ATO staff that raised concerns
about Mr Spence's behaviour.
Law enforcement sources say they are concerned
about the screening of ATO staff, including former
state and federal law enforcement officials who may
have left previous jobs under a cloud.
The Sunday Age confirmed that a small
number of former Victorian police officers who
resigned while under internal investigation have
been re-employed by other government agencies,
including the Victorian Workcover Authority, or as
investigators for large corporate firms. Some
maintain networks with serving police.
It is the second time that Mr Fitzgerald, a
NSW-based QC who headed the royal commission into
police corruption in Queensland in 1987, has
travelled to Victoria to conduct a corruption probe.
In 2004, he was appointed by state Ombudsman
George Brouwer to conduct a limited investigation
into the theft and leaking to the underworld of
sensitive police documents about murdered
police-corruption informer Terrence
Hodson.
State Opposition Leader Ted Baillieu seized on
the latest appointment of Mr Fitzgerald to raise
concerns about investigations into corruption and
misconduct in Victoria.
"We seem to have a piecemeal approach to
these investigations and the very many agencies
which are responsible for them find themselves with
their own conflicts and gaps in their
responsibilities."
Victoria's corruption framework falls short of
those interstate. The Queensland Crime and
Misconduct Commission, the WA Corruption and Crime
Commission and NSW's Independent Commission Against
Corruption can all investigate politicians and
public officials.
The Victorian Office of Police Integrity has
similar powers but is restricted to investigating
police misconduct. The Victorian Ombudsman is unable
to investigate commonwealth agencies, judicial
bodies, politicians, private individuals or
businesses, and cannot hold public hearings.
The Opposition has also renewed its call for Mr
Brouwer, who heads both the OPI and the Ombudsman's
office, to be removed as the head of one to avoid a
conflict of interest.
On
October 8, 2007, the Age reported that
Gatto was under fresh
investigation over his alleged links
to the gangland murder of Victor
Peirce.
Gatto was being
scrutinised by Victoria Police's
Purana taskforce over the killing of
Peirce in 2002.
An
associate of Gatto, Faruk
Orman, had been charged in June in
relation to the
Peirce murder, and two
other associates of Gatto,
Gatto is allegedly connected to the murder in the brief
of evidence served on Orman, although The
Age believes there is insufficient
evidence to warrant his charging.
Police were investigating Mr Gatto's dealings
with Vince Benvenuto and his brother
who are the sons of former Melbourne 'Godfather' Liborio Benvenuto and brothers
of slain fruit market boss Frank in the 48 hours before
Peirce's shooting as part of allegations
that he had prior knowledge of the
murder.
Peirce was shot around the time he had arranged to meet Vince Benvenuto
in Port Melbourne.
One piece of the puzzle in the investigation is
photographs secretly taken of Gatto meeting another member of the Benvenuto
family in the middle of a city park 48 hours before Peirce's murder.
Questions also surround contact between Gatto and
Vince Benvenuto in the hours before his murder.
Gatto's lawyer, Brian Rolfe, says that having
closely scrutinised the brief against Orman there "is not the slightest
possibility of Mr Gatto being implicated in (the murder of Peirce) in any
way".
Police will say only that their investigations
into the gangland murders are progressing.
The
Age also revealed that
authorities were separately
investigating Gatto's links to
former and serving police, including a
senior detective.
In 2007 Gatto and Matt Tomas were appointed directors of a private oil company.
Among Atlas Petroleum Pty
Ltd's three other directors are Dragos Niga, jailed for 18 months in the
mid-'90s for drug offences, and Steven Lazarevic, convicted in 2004 of firearm
and stolen goods offences.
Former
and serving investigators have told The
Age they are concerned about Mr
Gatto's reach into the police force.
The police's ethical standards
department recently investigated Mr
Gatto's alleged association with a
senior detective, although they have
been unable to question him because he
is on extended leave.
The
detective told The Age he had
occasionally greeted Mr Gatto —
sometimes with a kiss on the cheek —
after bumping into him at city
restaurants, but denied any
wrongdoing.
October
8, 2007, Age reporter Nick McKenzie wrote that Gatto
had said he'd gone straight. But investigations into
him and some of his associates just kept rolling on.
McKenzie wrote that Gatto, businessman, wanted a quiet life. "I just
wish you would stop f-----g asking people questions about me," he had told The
Age earlier in the year. "What I do is my business."
"The only story the former boxer wants told is that of redemption",
wrote McKenzie.
"Gatto now insists that he has gone straight, making an honest living in
construction, debt collection, even the oil sector.
"He is just a family man getting on with life who donates regularly to
charity and loves soccer. He was recently photographed with actor Simon Westaway,
who will play him in a TV mini-series about Melbourne's
underworld war — the picture has Gatto sitting at a restaurant table,
grinning, his large hand clutching a glass of wine."
And so it remains. As Gatto and his associates have traded their favourite
Lygon Street eateries for restaurants in the top end of Bourke Street, their
business interests have also shifted.
A close associate of Gatto, finance broker Tom
Karas, had recently played a key role in the acquisition of the building housing
one of the city's biggest nightclubs, the Metro.
The Age learned
that investigators and tax officials have been questioning nightclub figures
about whether Gatto is a source of money flowing into the industry.
Karas was also involved in an
investigation into the ownership of a racehorse linked to the Mokbel
family.
Nick McKenzie wrote that Gatto continued to charge building industry
figures thousands of dollars to iron out their problems with the unions.
He has no formal industrial or legal training,
but has close ties to industry players, including senior unionists, and an
uncanny ability to guarantee a deal.
Numerous industry figures say Gatto is
usually a pleasure to deal with.
But some concede he carries with him an
unspoken threat, deliberate or not, because of his underworld ties and history.
His presence in the construction industry
unsettles some, but not all.
John Setka is a senior official with the powerful
building union, the CFMEU.
Asked in 2007 whether he supported Gatto's deep
links with the industry, Setka answered: "The principle is you're innocent
until proven guilty. I mean, look, it is a building industry just like any other
industry and I suppose everyone is entitled to make a living."
Gatto also lashed out in 2007 at criticism of
his role in the construction industry.
"The people that deal with me say
that I'm a gentleman; I like to think that I am a gentleman. I've never stood
over anyone. There's no evidence of that."
Gatto's business interests extend offshore, as
well.
He partnered up with Melbourne businessman Andrew Harris in an
overseas venture, believed to be a stevedoring company.
"He is a fantastic bloke and we do a lot of
business together, although we do not socialise together," Harris told The
Age.
Harris is among many who vouch for the good
nature of Gatto who gives regularly to the Royal Children's Hospital
appeal.
On
December 24, 2007, John
Silvester wrote in the Age that
the
Purana gangland taskforce had
launched a long-term
investigation into Italian
organised crime, including
several unsolved murders.
Silvester wrote that
detectives
are looking into five
"hits" they suspect
may have been ordered by leading
Italian-Australian gangsters.
These include the murders of Gerardo
and Vince
Mannella,
Joe
Quadara, Frank
Benvenuto and Victor
Peirce.
The
cases have been officially
switched from the homicide squad
to Purana.
The
second Purana phase was to
investigate Tony
Mokbel's drug syndicate,
uncover his hidden financial
network, and find him. On June 5
this year Mokbel was arrested
in Greece and charged with
two murders and a string of drug
offences. He is expected to be
extradited by mid-next year.
Detective
Superintendent Richard Grant
said Purana would take on new
targets next year. He said
intelligence files were being
checked to identify a new crime
ring that required long-term
investigation.
Meanwhile,
homicide investigators have
found that a hitman who worked
for Williams also worked for
Italian gangsters. Andrew
"Benji" Veniamin
was considered to be Williams'
loyal lieutenant, but police now
believe he carried out three
contract killings for Italian
gangsters before Williams
recruited him.
They
believe his first known victim
was Joe Quadara, and he remains
the suspect for the murders of
Frank Benvenuto and Victor
Peirce.
Police
suspect Veniamin was the gunman
in seven underworld murders.
They say he shot dead Dino
Dibra, on October 14, 2000, Paul
Kallipolitis, whose body was
found on October 25, 2002, and
was the main suspect in the
murder of standover man Nik
Radev, who was shot dead on
April 15, 2003. Radev had an
appointment to see Veniamin on
the morning he was murdered, and
was also part of the torture
team that grabbed and killed
Mark Mallia in August 2003.
Police
say that both Peirce and
Veniamin worked for Benvenuto at
different times when the
apparently respectable
businessman felt the need to
intimidate enemies at the
wholesale fruit and vegetable
market.
Veniamin
was shot dead by a Melbourne
identity, Mick
Gatto, on March 23, 2004 in
a Carlton restaurant. Gatto was
acquitted of murder on the
grounds of self-defence.
Purana
detectives working on the
Italian murders have arrested a
man they allege was the driver
when Veniamin ambushed Peirce in
Bay Street, Port Melbourne.
Other inquiries into Gatto
are under way, although little
about them is publicly
known.
On
January
12,
2007,
the Herald Sun reported that the controversial bail justice investigated
over her closeness to Alphonse Gangitano
and Mick Gatto has broken her silence to
defend the executed crime boss.
That week marked a decade since Melbourne's
gangland war started with Gangitano's
execution.
Rowena
Allsop has spoken out on behalf of the
man many regarded as a cruel, violent
psychopath.
"I
get criticised every time I say he was a
friend, but that's what he was,"
she told the Sunday Herald Sun.
"I'm
not blind to the fact there was a side
to Alphonse that he was not proud of.
But the side I saw was the side of a
friend."
The
friendship between the bail justice and
the crime figure prompted an
investigation, which was dropped, by the
Attorney-General.
Ms Allsop
said her friendships with Carlton
identities were appropriate.
"I
think whenever there's a male-female
relationship people are always
fascinated," she said.
"I
think the fact the wife (of Gangitano)
asked me to give the eulogy certainly
puts paid to the claim I was his
mistress. But I was a female friend and
I met him always in public places."
Ms Allsop
said they became close friends over
coffee after a late-night court hearing.
"I
dealt with him through the courts. He
came before me on a couple of
occasions," she said.
Allegations
Ms Allsop had an "inappropriate
relationship" with Gatto were
referred to the Solicitor-General in
1998. Ms Allsop said she still spoke to
Gatto.
On March 11, 2008, a preliminary hearing for Faruk Orman began at Melbourne Magistrates' Court.
The court heard Peirce] was gunned down by Andrew Veniamin in a hearing for the accused getaway driver, 26, of Sunshine, who appeared at a commital hearing, charged with the murder of Peirce six years before.
Defence barrister Robert Richter QC told the court there was no question that "Benji" Veniamin killed Peirce, saying he undoubtedly planned and carried out the execution.
Mr Richter said much of the case against his client was based on claims by Venimain made to other parties including an informer that may not be admissible.
The informer was due to give evidence the next day.
Orman was remanded in custody.
On March 12, 2008, an underworld associate was asked if it was okay for hitman Andrew Veniamin to kill Victor Peirce, a court witness said.
The witness, known as witness B for legal reasons, told the court he approached underworld associate Michael Laverde two weeks before Peirce's murder to ask if it was okay for Veniamin to kill him.
He told the court he discussed the planned hit with Mr Laverde at his dry-cleaning business in suburban Coburg.
"I approached him because I thought he may have been friends with Victor Peirce," witness B told the court.
"He didn't care, as it was nothing to do with him," he said.
Witness B said that in the underworld there was an unwritten understanding if someone had been targeted, that it was discussed.
"In the underworld, if people are going to get knocked they ask others about it," witness B said.
"Some ask and some don't.
"Usually in the underworld ... if we can try to stop a shooting we will."
Witness B told the court that Veniamin confessed to Peirce's murder.
He said that Veniamin told him that he and Orman had planned to meet Peirce in a car park but saw him in Bay Street and decided to pull up alongside his car.
Witness B has denied any role in Peirce's murder.
He also told the court that Veniamin, who was shot dead in a Carlton restaurant in 2004, confessed to murdering another crime figure Dino Dibra in 2000.
He alleged that Orman had also been Veniamin's get-away driver in that murder.
On March 13, 2008, the court was told Victorian detectives were not told of phone intercepts which could have led them to the alleged killers of Peirce until five years after he was shot dead.
Melbourne Magistrates Court was also told an underworld associate was asked if it was okay for hitman Andrew Veniamin to kill Peirce.
Purana Taskforce Detective Sergeant Boris Buick told the court Orman became a suspect in Peirce's murder after the police informer known only as witness B made statements to police in 2006.
Those statements were corroborated by Australian Crime Commission telephone intercepts, Det Sgt Buick told the court.
"It was when he (Orman) was first nominated," he said.
"And after a review of Australian Crime Commission telephone intercepts which corroborated his (witness B) statements."
But he told the court Purana detectives did not know about the phone intercepts until five years after Peirce's murder.
"Telephone intercepts were held by the Australian Crime Commission and were not released to us until five years later," Det Sgt Buick said.
He said police had information showing Orman picked up Veniamin on the night of Peirce's murder, and both men's mobile phones were not used between 8.30pm and 11pm.
"It was about 8pm or shortly after on May 1, 2002 (Orman picked up Veniamin)," Det Sgt Buick said. "Both Veniamin and Orman turned their phones off during the time of the murder."
Witness B told the court he approached underworld associate Michael Laverde two weeks before Peirce's murder to ask if it was okay for Veniamin to carry out the hit.
He said he discussed the planned hit with Mr Laverde at his dry-cleaning business in suburban Coburg.
"I approached him because I thought he may have been friends with Victor Peirce," witness B said.
"He didn't care, as it was nothing to do with him."
Witness B said it was common for underworld figures to discuss when someone had been targeted, in order to avoid deaths.
"In the underworld, if people are going to get knocked they ask others about it," witness B said.
"Some ask and some don't. Usually in the underworld ... if we can try to stop a shooting we will."
Witness B has denied any role in Peirce's murder.
The court also heard Gatto helped Andrew Veniamin "set up"Peirce, who was killed before he could get revenge on the pair for killing Frank Benvenuto.
The underworld informer told police Peirce was murdered after he found out that Gatto had ordered Veniamin to kill Benvenuto.
Benvenuto, who hired Peirce as protection after a series of disputes at the market in the late 1990s, was shot dead outside his Beaumaris house on May 8, 2000.
"About two years after Frank's murder, Andrew said he heard Peirce had found out it was him who had killed Frank and he was worried that Peirce was going to get revenge on him and Mick Gatto. That's why he asked Mick to help him set up Peirce," the informer told police.
He said Veniamin had previously worked for Benvenuto but changed allegiances when Gatto found out Benvenuto had put a contract on his life.
"Andrew told me that Gatto gave him an ultimatum: that he come and work for him and take care of Frank Benvenuto or else Andrew would cop it," he said.
That evening Gatto denied the allegations, describing the informer as a renowned liar and the dead men as his friends, before adding: "The truth will come out."
The informer disputed rumours that Carl Williams ordered Peirce's murder because he reneged on a $200,000 deal to kill rival gangster Jason Moran. "(Williams) hadn't even met Andrew at this stage, as I was the one who introduced Andrew to Carl when he got out of jail after Peirce's murder," he told police.
Two statements made by the informer were tendered to Melbourne Magistrates Court.
The informer, a drug dealer who has confessed involvement in two gangland murders, said Orman was the driver for Veniamin
The informer said Gatto had Frank Benvenuto's brother, Vince Benvenuto, set up Peirce, to whom he was supplying drugs.
He said Vince Benvenuto arranged to meet Peirce at the rooftop car park of a Port Melbourne supermarket but, when Pierce didn't turn up, they arranged another meeting the following night.
The informer said Veniamin was "obsessed" with getting Peirce and became depressed when Pierce didn't show up to the first meeting. "Andrew's reputation was that of a killer. That was his profession and he loved it," he said. He said Veniamin asked for Gatto's help because he was having "a lot of trouble finding Peirce".
On March 13, 2008, Blues legend Peter Bosustow told how he played peacemaker between a leading underworld figure and a convicted murderer.
Bosustow said he'd been asked by Chopper Read to smooth relations with Mick Gatto and the so-called Carlton Crew.
The high-flying forward knew Gatto, along with Alphonse Gangitano and Mark and Jason Moran, through their fervent support for the Blues.
"You'd meet them as a celebrity footballer, and that's the way they would treat you," Bosustow told the Herald Sun.
He said they didn't regard him as a member of the underworld.
Bosustow, who played 65 games with the Blues between 1981 and 1983, and Read have done more than 300 public speaking engagements together since 2001.
He recalled the day Read told him he'd "had a problem with Mick Gatto, and Alphonse and Jason as well".
"I said to him that Mick was a one-eyed Carlton supporter, so he asked me to go and speak to Mick for him.
"I said I would. I was oblivious to what was going on. I wasn't in that area. So I just bowled into one of the Carlton restaurants one day, and Mick was there with his minder.
"We both shook hands and I sat down. I said, 'I need to talk to you about Chopper Read.'
"He said, 'Oh, yes.'
"I asked, 'Do you have a problem with Chopper Read?' He said, 'Absolutely not.' And I said, 'Well, Chopper said to me exactly the same thing.'
"He said, 'Buzz. If you see Chopper, then you tell him if I see him in Lygon St on a cafe strip I'll have a coffee with him'.
"And that was it. I reported to Chopper and he said, 'Good. That's it'."
Known widely as "The Buzz", Bosustow was close to Mark and Jason Moran, who were killed in Melbourne's violent underworld feuds.
One of the connections was through the Morans' grandfather, Leo Brooks, a Blues stalwart with whom Bosustow boarded when he came to Melbourne from Perth.
Leo Brooks died about a month before Mark Moran was murdered.
Bosustow recalled Brooks's funeral, where mourners included 30 or 40 gangsters, including Jason Moran in handcuffs.
"I spoke to Jason a week and a half before he was murdered. He was in Perth to 'sort out something'," Bosustow said.
"That's the sort of guy he was. Business was business to him and pleasure was a different thing."
Asked if he believed Moran had an inkling of what lay ahead for him, Bosustow said: "I think he knew. He had to be very silly if he didn't know.
"I spoke to Mark about four weeks before he was murdered. He was petrified."
Bosustow said he did not attend either brother's funeral.
He said the Underbelly TV series, which cannot be shown in Victoria for legal reasons, was a hit in Western Australia, where he lives.
"It's captured the imagination of everyone here. Everybody is talking about it," he said.
"Jason and Mark are household names. I don't know if that is good. Jason was a very vicious boy."
In the March 16, 2008, Sunday Herald Sun, Gatto broke a three-year silence to refute claims he was behind several unsolved underworld hits.
Gatto and his legal team said they have information that contradicts the allegations made against him.
Mr Gatto's team may produce documentary evidence in a bid to clear his name.
Mr Gatto and his lawyers say his name is being tarnished despite the fact that there are no charges against him.
"I find these allegations scurrilous," Mr Gatto said.
"I've never arranged a hit on anyone."
Mr Gatto said he believed he was being defamed as part of a personal vendetta.
He said he believed it was happening because as far as police were concerned, "I'm the only one who's got through the loop".
"It's annoying for me. It's annoying for my family. It's annoying for everyone. Personally I just want to be left alone."
Mr Gatto said he had told police he was prepared to be interviewed if he was suspected of anything, but they had not taken up the offer.
He said that otherwise his life was good.
"I've got no complaints. I try to mind my own business and keep my head held high," Mr Gatto said.
But he said he believed modern policing was eroding civil liberties.
Saying that the police have a powerful tool, Mr Gatto said "they can put people up (in custody) for 23 hours a day with no contact with the outside world until they've rolled over".
"And once they've rolled over, they turn them into puppets. Accused people who are innocent until proven guilty are locked away in a little eight-by-four room," he said.
"They drive people to the point that they are so desperate, they say anything at all to get out of there."
Mr Gatto had avoided the limelight since being acquitted of murdering Veniamin in 2005.
He said the previous week that reports Veniamin was "like a son to him" were not accurate.
"I used to see him once a week, once a fortnight. He was a powerful little figure over in Sunshine," he said.
A Victoria Police spokewoman declined to respond to Mr Gatto's comments.
On March 29, 2008, Gatto had one of his proudest moments at son Damien's wedding at St Mary's Star of the Sea Church in West Melbourne.
At the wedding of Mr Gatto Jr and model Fiona Scali. Mr Gatto Sr was left holding the baby -- 15-week-old grandson Dominic and bragged he would be "the next heir".
The Herald Sun were told you couldn't wipe the smile off Mick Gatto's face as he joined son Damien and his fiancee, at their engagement party in February 2007.
The paper believed the do, at the Waterfront in Port Melbourne, had close to 400 guests, including several well-known underworld figures, local boxing identities and, of course, models.
Two bottles of Johnnie Walker Blue label scotch, worth $295 each, graced every table. 'What can be next for the wedding?', Confidential asked.
On April 7, 2008, the Age reported that it had learned
that Gatto had intervened in the dramatic collapse of stockbroking firm Opes Prime.
The broker collapsed after a handful of wealthy
clients suffered losses totalling $128 million.
Gatto was working on behalf of an anonymous group of investors trying to recoup their losses.
A director of Opes Prime had been ordered by a judge not to leave Australia as fresh allegations emerged of manipulation and cover-ups in the lead-up to the collapse two weeks
before.
Opes Prime owed more than $1 billion.
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission had obtained a Federal Court order forcing Opes Prime director Julian Smith to surrender his passport — days before he had planned to go on a holiday to Fiji.
The order came on the eve of a series of meetings on April 7 in which hundreds of angry Opes Prime clients who
were owed more than $500 million would be given an update on the fate of their savings by the firm's administrators.
The
above photo shows Opes Prime co-founder Lirim "Laurie"
Emini (left), fellow director Julian Smith (right) and Mick
Gatto (centre).
Gatto was to fly to Singapore with a business associate to pursue the Opes Prime money trail, but declined to reveal who he would be seeing there or who he was representing.
Mr Gatto told The Age: "These Opes Prime clients can take their chances and lose all their money to lawyers and to the receivers, or they can take their chances with me to extract a return on their behalf.
"The proof is in the pudding with me. I solve problems … It's my way or the highway".
Barrister Nicola Gobbo confirmed that Mr Gatto would be travelling overseas to try to track down money and shares related to Opes Prime.
Asked about Mr Gatto's clients, she said: "Some would be described as business people, if you very loosely used the term 'business people'."
It was believed that Mr Gatto planned to travel to the British Virgin Islands, depending on how he fared in Singapore.
ASIC had been examining transactions between a company registered in the British Virgin Islands
(which has an office in Singapore).
ASIC
had also been paying close attention to accounts linked with Sydney solicitor Chris
Murphy (left), a major client of Opes Prime.
Murphy is believed to be one of Opes's biggest debtors and thought to have lost more than $100
million.
Olympic hero Herb Elliott lost more than $20 million.
The previous week, an affidavit sworn by senior ASIC investigator Richard Vandeloo alleged that
Mr Emini directed staff to transfer shares or cash between the Virgin Island company's account and accounts operated by Mr Murphy or other Opes clients.
The regulator said fellow director Mr Smith may have been involved in covering up massive losses for certain clients just before the stockbroking firm collapsed.
ASIC also made fresh allegations about "double-counting" of shares, a practice it says shielded a handful of favoured clients from losing millions of dollars against their rapidly deteriorating share portfolios.
Mr Emini consented to a court order barring him from leaving the country until October 3.
ASIC then obtained urgent orders from Justice Ray Finkelstein in the Federal Court forcing Sydney-based Mr Smith to hand over his passport.
He had booked a 10-day holiday in Fiji with his family and was due to leave on April 13.
He agreed to ASIC's request that he hand over his passport, but his lawyers then withdrew the offer, saying ASIC had no power to request the travel documents. Mr Smith declined to comment.
ASIC also told the Federal Court that initial investigations and interviews with an Opes employee had uncovered "systematic manipulation" of share-trading accounts.
In support of its travel ban against Mr Smith, Mr Vandeloo outlined how shares held in an Opes account, identified only as "EE", were lent to a company called Leveraged Capital Pty Ltd, then routed through a company registered in the British Virgin Islands before being delivered back to Opes.
Leveraged Capital was jointly owned by Mr Emini and Mr Smith.
Its registered office is at the same address as the Babo Group accounting firm in Cramer Street, Preston.
In his affidavit, Mr Vandeloo said there was some "double-counting" of shares in the EE account, and that the effect of this "was to avoid margin calls on certain client accounts".
He said Mr Emini and Mr Smith were suspected of having "an interest" in another account identified as "BB", which had defaulted on paying $38 million. It was suspected that the default had been concealed before the failure of Opes Prime.
Meanwhile, the fallout from the collapse had spread, with the ANZ bank partly blaming its exposure to the broker for a $1 billion bad debts problem.
Gatto's
associates who left the country with him were John Khoury (left)
and long-time friend and business associate, Matt
Thomas.
Mr Khoury, once a Metro nightclub owner, is believed to have lost $1 million in
Opes.
Another close friend, State Security investment
adviser and former joint Metro owner Tom Karas, said he had moved money out
before the collapse after hearing rumours.
But it was unclear whether
his money, in a clearing account within Opes, was safe.
The Herald Sun had earlier written that it believed Mr Karas had
links to the Mokbel crime family.
My Karas' wife was an owner of star racehorse Pillar f Hercules, a
thoroughbred police believed was actually owned by the Mokbels.
Khoury said a few friendly words to the media at Tullamarine Airport as did
Gatto.
Gatto and Khoury were wearing bright t-shirts with large A-Team type emblems on their
fronts (see photo page top).
Before the trio boarded a flight for Sinapore Mr Gatto was coy on the issue of their overseas dealings.
While Gatto did not have any money tied up with Opes, many of his friends had hundreds of millions of dollars frozen inside the company.
He said he and his associates would "give it a shake".
"I really can't divulge too much at this point," Mr Gatto told a throng of reporters at Melbourne airport.
"We're going to do our best. Hopefully we recover whatever we can from them. There's a lot better chance with us than anyone else, I guarantee you."
And the trio were confident of success
Mr Gatto said he hoped he would need a "tip truck" to bring investors' money back to Australia.
"A percentage of something is better than nothing," he said.
"And whatever that percentage is depends on how much we're chasing.
"It happens every one or two years - long, drawn out affairs that the solicitors and the lawyers end up with all the money and the poor investor gets nothing."
Mr Gatto told 3AW radio that morning that he was travelling on behalf of his own and "another couple" of companies.
"I've been known to fix up sticky problems as you're aware. A couple of people have approached us and asked us if we could assist them and we said we're interested," he said.
"We're certainly not police, we're not there to uncover any fraud, we just want to recoup the money and do the right thing by everybody."
Gatto was reluctant to go into specifics on who his clients were and how much they were owed, but he did claim that the amount missing was far higher than the figure that has been made public.
"My role purely is to help these investors for a minimal upfront fee," he said.
"The services we provide are simple - we go and see the client, we say we really think that you should pay, it's all done amicably and nine times out of 10 it's settled.
"The client's happy, we're happy and of course the bloke that owes the money is happy to get that weight off his chest."
Gatto had told The Australian that he believed the amount owed to be over $1 billion, and that he had "a good track record of tracking things down".
Gatto would not reveal the countries he planned to visit outside of Singapore or say how long he would be away.
Opes Prime had operations that spanned Singapore and the Middle East.
"It's not just Singapore, we'll be darting around all different countries," said Gatto
that morning. "All roads lead to Rome as they say, wherever the job takes us we'll go."
Gatto flew
first-class into Singapore on the evening of April
8, 2008.
But the man disgruntled investors were believed to
be paying him to find, Jay Moghe, was 2500km away at a conference in Macau.
And Mr Moghe told the Herald Sun he was
unaware of Gatto's mission to Singapore.
"I've nothing to hide," he said.
"I'm happy to talk to anyone."
The sole shareholder and director of a company, Riqueza, then at the centre of the Opes collapse, said he was unaware of
irregular transactions between it and the Melbourne-based broker.
"The movements of whatever cash and stock in
and out of these (Riqueza) accounts was not anything to do with me," he
said. "I was effectively acting as a nominee for the Opes directors.
"I'm disappointed, and shattered," he
said.
Administrator John Lindholm laughed off Gatto's claims that he had more chance than lawyers and administrators of
getting back investors' money.
He said anyone who gave Mr Gatto money would
still be pursued by legal means and have to hand over twice as much.
Debts would only be discharged when money was
paid to the administrator.
Opes creditors were told they could
expect to lose 70 per cent of their money once secured creditors, including the
ANZ Bank and Merrill Lynch, got their money.
In other developments:
A HEROIN trafficker and former strip club owner
said he'd been about to invest $50,000 through the broker but filled in
paperwork incorrectly.
THE Australian Securities and Investments
Commission was believed to be investigating claims that parties with links to
Melbourne's underworld were using Opes to illegally "wash trade"
shares.
Wash trading involves buying and selling shares
to give an appearance of investor interest in a company, to encourage others.
The wash traders then sell their shares to the tricked investors at inflated
prices.
On the night of April 10, 2008, Gatto caught up with Opes Prime key player Jay Moghe in Singapore.
Mr Moghe was accompanied by Opes Prime figures Gordon Brown and Raj Maiden.
Originally scheduled to take place at the 60th floor luxury bar of the Swissotel the Stamford, the private meeting was reportedly moved twice before the group settled in for a chat.
When they emerged, Gatto told the Herald Sun Mr Moghe had been very transparent.
"He took us through ABC and we are satisfied they have done the right thing," he said. "They have reported everything to the authorities."
Gatto said the $100 million moved through Mr Moghe's company, Riqueza BVI, without his knowledge.
When asked for proof, Gatto said it would all come out in the wash.
Gatto and Khoury had a list of others they said may have held important information about key accounts Opes Prime moved money into in a bid to prevent fatal margin calls
in March 2008.
On it were two Collins St traders, one who they say handled up to 100 per cent loans for $21 million in small mining stocks, and another who handled up to $4 million.
They also wanted to speak with a Sydney shareholder who had more than $100 million in shares.
But one broker who knew two of those on Mr Gatto's list said neither would have access to the large sums of money transacted and were only conducting trades on behalf of Opes and clients.
"These were second tier guys . . . they used to trade shares, and that was it," the broker said.
On the evening of April 11, 2008, Gatto returned to Australia without any money for victims of the collapse.
He said there was nothing for
investors in Singapore.
"The money is all gone," he said.
"We are coming back without anything."
Mr Gatto said Singapore directors of Opes were
living in rented houses and had produced records showing how shareholder funds
had been wiped out by falling stockmarkets.
"We failed to find anything because there is
nothing there."
In other developments:
TWO luxury cars were seized by Opes receivers in
Australia as well as five in Singapore. The sale proceeds of another luxury car
sold in Australia were also seized.
PRIVATE investors have been offering to buy penny
dreadful stock ANZ Bank has been stuck with for a fraction of its worth.
Investors believe if they can get the stock at a discount they will be able to
sell it for a profit over an extended period.
Gatto's associate John Khoury claimed the
mission could still be ranked a success because it had sped up the discovery
process.
"We have fast-tracked everything," he
said.
"These guys (Jay Moghe) came forward and put
their hand up.
"Hopefully the investors do get more than
the 30 cents in the dollar.
"They are very happy." he said of the
six investors who had engaged Mr Gatto to chase funds.
Gatto would not say whether he would continue
his hunt for the money upon his return but hinted he would look at
Chris Murphy's Opes debts.
"When we get to Melbourne we are going to
see what happens from there," Mr Gatto said.
"At this stage we are closing our books here
(in Singapore)."
Murphy later recalled a red Maserati given to him as a gift by Laurie Emini.
"I thought it was very generous at the time," he said.
"Then
I hit the kerb when I parked it, and the mechanic said it was going to cost me
$8000 to fix. Then it was another $10,000 to register and insure - $18,000 all
up. I thought 'stuff it'. I drove it for eight weeks, until the rego ran out,
and then got rid of it. Too much of a spiv's car for me."
On
April 12, 2008, the Herald Sun reported that the Australian Taxation Office had launched an investigation into the "colourful
identities" embroiled in the Opes Prime saga.
Tax Office bosses ordered the investigation after
allegations of share price manipulation and clandestine companies and identities
being set up to disguise the owners of shares in some companies.
On
April 13, 2008, the it was reported that high-profile Sydney
lawyer Chris Murphy, the man at the epicentre of the collapse of Opes Prime,
had broken his silence and told The Sunday Age
that the failed stockbroking firm allowed him to keep trading as his losses
mounted.
Mr Murphy also said the previous two weeks had taken a huge toll on his health
and his family's wellbeing.
Mr Murphy contacted The Sunday Age to correct a report that two
Opes Prime trading accounts he held - one through his private company Cardiac
Jolt and another through the company Sarah Brown, which he co-owned with Laurie
Emini - should have been the
subject of a margin call as early as July 2007.
Copies of Mr Murphy's Opes Prime portfolio statements were obtained by
Gatto and John Khoury during their
trip to
Singapore.
"The statements that have been released only cover my exposure in
Sarah Brown and Cardiac Jolt," Mr Murphy said.
"They don't cover my
account in my own name and its shareholding.
Opes let customers combine the
total value of their holdings in all their accounts, which is one of the
reasons why I never received a margin call."
Mr Murphy said that on July 13, 2007 - the date of the Opes Prime
statements obtained by Gatto and Khoury that had been leaked to the
public - he also had a holding of 10,660,000 shares of Challenger in his
private account, "account number 5493", worth $55 million.
"I had borrowed $38 million against them, I had about one-third equity
in them - and an available margin of $16.2 million that Opes offset against
the other accounts."
Mr Murphy also told The Sunday Age that he had been in contact
with Mr Emini only once in the past month, despite the pair owning a share
portfolio that had lost more than $60 million.
On the day of Opes Prime's collapse, Tom Karas told The Sunday Age: "Chris Murphy
is the black hole. Chris Murphy and Sarah Brown - that's where all the money's
gone. And it's all gone down the hole on Challenger."
Mr Murphy was a
substantial shareholder in the James Packer-controlled Challenger Financial
Services Group. It was the collapse of Challenger's share price, which fell
65% in six months, that wiped out Mr Murphy's share portfolio.
According to the documents obtained by Gatto and Khoury, Sarah
Brown's Opes Prime account had fallen almost $1 million into the red by July
last year - it had borrowed $65.89 million against a share portfolio worth
$64.94 million. It was paying an interest rate of 7.85% on that loan.
Cardiac Jolt's account shows that it had borrowed $102.3 million against
shares worth $108 million. Its interest rate was 8.1%.
Mr Murphy confirmed to The Sunday Age that he was given a loan
valuation ratio (LVR) of 95% - meaning he could borrow up to 95% of the value
of the highly speculative shares he owned.
The Sarah Brown and Cardiac Jolt accounts had combined borrowings in excess
of $167 million, and were charged interest rates on that money comparable to a
home mortgage.
Asked if the 95% LVR and the interest rates he was charged by Opes were
"generous", Mr Murphy replied: "Well, that's your
opinion."
In another twist, a race had been on to track down a fleet of exotic cars
that belonged to Hawkswood Investments, a fully owned unit of Opes Prime.
Already 13 sports cars, worth more than $1 million, had been seized in
Singapore.
Mark Hawthorne commented in the Sunday Age that
the Opes Prime collapse had spawned a saga of fast cars and fast
footwork keeping accountants and colourful identities busy.
A race has been on for the past week between Opes Prime's receivers, led by
the Deloitte forensic accountancy team, and Melbourne's underworld, led by a
man named "Rocky", to track down the missing sports cars. The smart
money, all along, has been on Rocky to find them first.
The cars once belonged to Hawkswood Investments, a fully owned subsidiary
of Opes Prime. The stockbroking company's three directors — Laurie Emini, Julian Smith and Anthony Blumberg — were also
directors of Hawkswood. Among its many sideline businesses, Hawkswood imported
flashy European cars, which were shipped from Singapore to Australia.
It was a happy sideline for one director in particular, Mr Blumberg, who
had a well-known penchant for fast Italian cars. Thanks to his love of speed,
Opes Prime even sponsored a V8 Supercar team.
Among the many documents Gatto and his travel companions managed to get their hands on
while in Singapore was a list of sports cars that belonged to Hawkswood.
But Gatto and Khoury weren't interested in cars that weren't on their
own turf, particularly as Gatto vowed to bring back "suitcases full of
cash" for burnt Opes Prime clients.
After obtaining the documents they had sought in Singapore, their attention
turned to the Hawkswood cars in Melbourne, particularly those linked with Mr
Blumberg.
According to Gatto, his own speciality these days is "making
problems disappear". Long-time friend John Khoury has a different skill
set. "John's good at finding things," one of their business
associates told The Sunday Age.
A list of the cars in question was sent from Khoury in Singapore to
Rocky in Melbourne, and the hunt was on.
Deloitte refused to divulge details of the cars being sought, but Rocky
was more willing to oblige.
"One Ferrari Daytona, olive green, sold before Opes Prime
collapsed," he said, reading from his list.
"One silver Lamborghini Diablo 1996, right-hand drive, red. One
Ferrari 360 Spider. One Ferrari F355, right-hand drive, red, 1997. One Ferrari
F355, right-hand drive, blue, 1997. One Ferrari 360 Spider. One yellow Hummer.
Two rare Maseratis, late 1950s, maybe early 1960s, both left-hook. One Ferrari
250 GTO Californian, short-wheel base, aluminium body, no wheels."
The list went on.
Within hours Khoury's team, led by Rocky, was calling its contacts in
Melbourne on the lookout for the cars.
One, a Ferrari, was traced to the workshop of a well-known mechanic in
Brighton, just a few minutes' drive from Mr Blumberg's house.
By the time Rocky turned up, it had gone.
"Someone tipped him off," Rocky said. "I heard it was
someone related to Leo Khouri. Whoever it was, (name withheld) knew we were
coming."
Leo Khouri is the well-known Melbourne share trader who, along with some of
his business associates, lost an estimated $50 million share portfolio in the
collapse of Opes Prime.
Like Mr Blumberg, Mr Khouri
(left) has a love of fast cars. He and business
partner Steve Dellidis (right) own Australia's biggest collection of GTHO and GT
Falcons — 16 cars in total, with an estimated market value of $5 million.
Rocky knows that some of the cars have already fallen into the hands of the
receivers, a fact confirmed by Deloitte partner Chris Campbell.
"We have got some cars in Australia, and we're searching down some
others and we've got (five or six) Maseratis in Singapore under our
control," he said.
"We've found a few here, and some of them are in our possession and
some of them we're still tracing down. If (other) people get a heads-up about
what we're looking for, the asset might disappear, or they might put blocks in
front of us."
Sadly for Mr Campbell, some of those assets have already been uncovered.
In addition to the Ferrari in Brighton, the olive green Ferrari has already
been sold — apparently to a well-known Melbourne dealer of rare cars. The
dealer remained silent for a long time when contacted by The Sunday Age,
then denied any knowledge of the vehicle.
Mr Khoury's men plan to check into the sale of that car very carefully. But
Rocky really hit paydirt when he received a call telling him to go to a
warehouse in Moorabbin, run by a man known in underworld circles as "Big
Fat Bruno".
The warehouse is hardly in a salubrious part of Melbourne, located in an
industrial estate and surrounded by factories.
It's the last place you'd expect to find two Ferraris but, when The
Sunday Age arrived, two 1997 model F355 Ferraris, one red, one blue, and
both right-hand drive, were sitting in the middle of his warehouse, surrounded
by luxury sports cars, including Porsches and a Corvette, in varying states of
repair.
Bruno was sitting on a stool, sipping a coffee. Signs saying "not for
sale" were on the windscreens of the two Ferraris.
"One's mine, one belongs to a client," Bruno said. "I'm a
legitimate businessman."
Of note, one of the cars, said to be the one belonging to a client, had the
Victorian custom licence plate AB 010.
"Mr Anthony Blumberg?" we inquired.
"Who?" replied Bruno.
Bruno said he had "absolutely no underworld links" at all.
Apart from once going to school with Mick Gatto. And knowing him "from
the Carlton days".
Bruno said the two cars were "definitely not the ones everyone is
looking for".
"I've had calls all week, mate," he said. "Everyone's
looking for some missing cars. Tell me, if I find them, is there a
reward?"
On April 27, 2008, the Herald Sun reported that former world boxing champion Jeff Fenech
had turned to Gatto for help as he prepared his comeback bout against Ghana's Azumah Nelson.
Fenech, 43, had begun training at Gatto's in-house ring and gym, and has lost 18kg in seven weeks.
Sydney-based Fenech said he planned to train every morning at Chatteau Gatto in Lower Plenty in the lead up to his June 24 grudge match
against Nelson, expected to be held at Vodaphone Arena.
"I've known Mick for a while but for the last four or five years spent quality time with him. I've been to his family weddings and I respect him a great deal," Fenech said.
Gatto won five of his nine professional fights from 1973-79 and was ranked in the top ten heavyweights in Australia, said Fenech would "destroy Nelson in the clash of the triple world champions.
"He's been a good friend of mine in hard times, and he's a great champ," Gatto said.
Fenech said he thought Nelson, 49, would "try to knock me out, but he;'s no fitter than me. No one trains harder than I do".
On April 24, 2008, fists were flying at Malvern Town Hall on Anzac Day eve when Shannon MacMahon claimed the Bob Rose Cup with a fourth-round knock-out of Tom Hateley.
But there was as much interest outside the ring as was it in, with some colourful identities spotted in the crowd.
Former Collingwood player Rene Kink presented the cup, named in honour of former Magpie great Rose, to MacMahon.
Former world boxing champion Lester Ellis was ringside while ex-Melbourne captain Robbie Flower was also spotted along with
Gatto, Kink's new sparring partner.
On May 4, 2008, the Sunday Herald Sun asked: "What happens when a TV reporter gets into the ring with
Mick Gatto?" The answer?: "Simple: the reporter gets decked".
That's exactly what happened to A Current Affair's Martin King, who was assigned to interview the Carlton identity.
Gatto had agreed to talk to King as long he faced off for a bout in the boxing ring of his palatial suburban Melbourne home.
King agreed and stood face-to-face with the former professional fighter. Minutes later Gatto landed a jarring left hook to King's face that sent him sprawling to the canvas.
"It was fun until he actually started to hit me," King said.
"The first punch in the head is worse because it's shock and pain, after that it's just pain. I actually landed quite a few punches but what worried me was, I think Mick quite enjoyed it.
"The thing is, I didn't want to hit him too hard because all that would do was make him angry and that wouldn't be healthy for any of us."
King has a bit of swelling and bruising, tender ribs and a fractured ego.
The interview - and knockout punch - was shown on A Current Affair.
On June 23, 2008, Gatto and radio presenter Derryn Hinch had an entertaining on-air spat.
A war of words erupted on 3AW after Hinch berated underworld figures for cashing in on their celebrity status.
Mick Gatto rang Hinch's radio show, furious over Hinch's comments.
He told Hinch he hoped he died soon.
Gatto told Hinch: "You are scum and I tell you what, I've got a punching bag at home with your name on it," he said.
Hinch delivered a few punchlines of his own, telling Gatto he'd be happy to "burn him".
"If burning you was my job in life I'd be more than happy to do it," Hinch said.
"I think you and all your ilk, and all your mob and the Carlton Crew and the Carl Williamses of this world, you are all scum."
Gatto said it was "ratbags" like Hinch that kept him in the limelight.
"I want to be left alone and mind my own business and get on with my life, but I can't because I've got maggots like you driving me mad," Gatto complained.
Hinch sounded unfazed.
"If I can go to my grave being called a maggot by a person like Mick Gatto, I'm proud of myself," Hinch said.
Hinch hinted at Gatto's links with the underworld.
"You live in that world where people go to their graves quickly, don't you?" Hinch said.
Gatto hung up shortly after, telling Hinch: "Hope you die very soon."
On June 24, 2008, the Herald Sun reported that Gatto's son had taken aim at radio presenter Derryn Hinch on a facebook page calling him a "scumbag"
The facebook group "DERRYN HINCH IS A SCUMBAG" was created earlier in the day by a person claiming to be Damien Gatto.
The group already had 98 members.
On the facebook page, Damien Gatto said he had had enough of Hinch speaking about his dad.
"The only reason i published this was becuse im sick of this fool bagging my father week after week," Damien Gatto wrote.
"This group is for those who are sick of this f****** idiot and his trouble making opinions.
"Really speaks volumes for the credibility of 3AW and the substance of their reporting when they feel the need to publish this story on their website... Unbelievable."
On June 25, 2008, it was reported that a court had heard the nephew of Gatto would plead guilty to assault charges over an incident outside a nightclub in Melbourne's inner-east.
Daniel Gatto, from Templestowe, would enter guilty pleas to three charges - one count of recklessly causing injury, one of unlawful assault and one of recklessly causing serious injury - his lawyer Colin Lovett, QC, told Melbourne Magistrates Court.
Magistrate Duncan Reynolds extended bail for Gatto, 24, who appeared in court.
The charges relate to an alleged incident outside a Prahran nightclub on December 24, 2004.
On July 5, 2008, three $100,000 rewards were re-offered to help solve Melbourne gangland murders.
They said they believe the killings are linked and offered a $100,000 reward a murder for information leading to the arrest and conviction of those responsible.
Police said there were no rules stopping gangland figures such as Carl Williams receiving the rewards.
"I don't make that decision, but he is eligible to apply," Det Insp Bernie Edwards, of the Purana Taskforce, said.
Detectives believe Andrew "Benji" Veniamin was the shooter in all three murders, but they want to identify other people involved.
"We do not believe Andrew worked alone," Det Insp Edwards said.
He said involvement in the murders could include financing the hits, or providing or disposing of firearms and cars.
Purana detectives were "definitely closing in on a number of suspects", he added, and warned it might be time for anyone involved to hand themselves in "before we come and get you".
The suspects were known within the "gangland fraternity", but Det Insp Edwards refused to say whether any of them were already in jail.
Det Insp Edwards said he hoped the rewards, which had been offered separately at different times in the past seven years, would help people do the right thing and contact police.
"The code of silence wavers a lot when there's money involved," he said.
The Victoria Police board of management determines whether a reward application is successful.
"It depends on the information they provide (and) whether there is a successful prosecution," Det Insp Edwards said.
"Solving the three murders would take police a great step towards finishing the gangland murders."
Det Insp Edwards said it was getting easier to crack underworld crime because, while older criminals were a "lot stauncher", modern crooks were "a little bit self-centred".
On July 14, 2008, Vince Benvenuto was charged of the murder of Victor Peirce.
The Age reported the following day that the charge had put a fresh focus on
Gatto's alleged links to the killing.
Law enforcement authorities have information that Gatto was in contact with members of the Benvenuto family before Peirce's killing. On one occasion shortly before the murder, Gatto was covertly recorded meeting another member of the Benvenuto family in a city park.
It is believed that about the same time, Veniamin - who had formed a relationship with Gatto - was trying to find a way to lure Peirce to a location where he could be killed.
Benvenuto was to return to court on November 3.
On July 16, 2008, it was reported that Gatto had said police should charge him over the two murders or back off.
Mr Gatto said police were yet to produce any evidence he had been involved.
"If they're going to come and arrest me, come out and do it," he told the Herald Sun.
"I'll come up trumps, I promise."
Mr Gatto accused the Purana Taskforce of "putting the squeeze" on two suspects in the Peirce killings to implicate him.
He said one of the men, who has been in custody for months, had been made a series of offers to name him as involved.
"It's just wrong. They shouldn't be allowed to do it," he said.
"There's been an agenda with me for a long time. It's why they're squeezing these blokes. Go out and get evidence."
Gatto's legal representatives, Grigor Lawyers, wrote to Purana, accusing it of peddling innuendo about him.
The letter stated the talk was damaging his legitimate business activities and had the potential to endanger his life.
"Mr Gatto has answered questions in various interviews and hearings, both prior to and since his acquittal on a murder charge," it said.
"He remains prepared to fully co-operate with your investigators if he is able to assist with your inquiry.
"It would be most unfortunate if there was any suggestion that he had refused to co-operate with an investigation in any future proceedings that may involve him."
Victoria Police declined to comment on Gatto's claims.
Mr Gatto said he knew Vince Benvenuto but only spoke to him every few months, and not in the lead-up to Peirce's death.
He said nothing had changed since he was acquitted in 2005 over the shooting death of Andrew Veniamin.
"It's been three years since I've been home. Nothing's changed," he said.
Mr Gatto said the situation reminded him of the scrutiny he was placed under after the 1988 killing of another gangland identity.
He was then questioned by homicide squad officers over the shooting of Joe Arena.
"It's exactly the same. There's not an iota of evidence," Gatto said.
On
July 17, 2008, Gatto's youngest son was convicted and fined $1500 over a
car accident that left him in intensive care.
Justin Gatto, 23, lost control of his BMW and collided with a car on
Macarthur Rd, Parkville on November 28, 2007.
Melbourne
Magistrates' Court heard Gatto, a rigger at his father's crane company, was
tired and had lost concentration while driving home from a day working in the
hot sun.
His car ran off the road, hit the curb, and slid sideways into the path of a
four-wheel-drive.
Barrister Nicola Gobbo said Gatto is still recovering from severe injuries.
The court heard he was admitted to intensive care at the Royal
Melbourne Hospital with a fractured pelvis and elbow, dislocated shoulder,
punctured lung, and blood clotting.
The driver of the 4WD was treated at the scene for a fractured tailbone.
Gatto, of Lower Plenty, pleaded guilty today to one count of careless
driving.
Ms Gobbo said Gatto had no criminal history, and would return to work on his
surgeon's advice after pins in his elbow are removed.
A magistrate convicted Gatto, fined him $1500 and cancelled his driving
licence for six months.
On July 29, 2008, Purana taskforce detectives arrested Angelo Mario Venditti, a Melbourne businessmen and associate of Gatto, over the murder of western suburban drug identity Paul Kallipolitis.
Venditti, 43, from Aspendale Gardens, was interviewed by police and then appeared in court charged with murder along with another man who cannot be identified for legal reasons.
He sat quietly in Melbourne Magistrates Court as the charge was read out.
Kallipolitis, a close running mate of underworld figures Andrew Veniamin and Dino Dibra, was shot at close range in his Nicholson Pde home in West Sunshine on 15 October 2002.
Kallipolitis's murder is believed to be linked to the shooting deaths of underworld figures Victor Peirce in 2002 and Frank Benvenuto in 2000.
A $100,000 reward for each of those murders is still on offer for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible.
The prosecutor, Diana Karamicov, said today a brief of evidence would be served on Vendiitti's solicitor, Dean Cole by October 7.
Magistrate Jim Mornane remanded the heavy set and unshaven Venditti in custody to appear in November.
Venditti's name surfaced during operation Barrator, an investigation looking at Mick Gatto, which began in early 2003 and is reported above.
On August 27, 2008, it was
reported that Mick Gatto had
been accused of pressuring businessmen, builders and trade unionists to
attend a charity event that will finance the legal defence of accused
murderer Faruk Orman.
The fund-raiser has infuriated police and
victims-of-crime organisations, which said Orman should pay his own legal
costs.
Tickets for the gala dinner at the
Docklands' Atlantic function room on September 17 cost $1000, with the
event expected to raise more than $500,000 to cover the fees of
high-profile defence barrister Robert Richter, QC.
It included a three-course meal and
entertainment by singer Vanessa Amorosi. Cricket legend Shane Warne and
boxing great Jeff Fenech are believed to have donated memorabilia for an
auction.
But several people approached by Gatto
said they were reluctant to pay for Orman's high-profile defence.
"To be honest, I don't want to stump
up $10,000 for a bloke I've never met. And there's no way I want to be
seen at something like that," one businessman said.
He said Gatto had "put the hard
word" on several business associates over the previous two weeks.
A member of the Construction, Forestry,
Mining and Energy Union said he would not be attending but knew several
union officials who had bought tickets.
"I don't want to say too much, but
there will be a few union blokes heading along,' he said. "But it
really has nothing to do with the union; it's more them supporting
Mick."
Senior detectives were understood to be
furious that a host of well-connected business and sporting figures had
agreed to finance the defence.
Gatto denied pressuring
anyone.
"All the people that are coming are
coming because they're friends of mine and they support an innocent
man," he said.
"It's completely lawful what we're
doing, and I do it with my head held high. We look after our friends, we
don't hang them out to dry."
Crime Victims Support Association president
Noel McNamara was outraged by the event.
"It's a bloody disgrace. He (Orman) is
entitled to a defence, but why should he get the best defence
available?" Mr McNamara said.
Mr Richter was not concerned that his legal
fees would be funded by the dinner. "Providing funds for the defence
are raised by legitimate means, I don't inquire as to how," he said.