Dr Tim
Watson-Munro
Watson-Munro was a
high profile Melbourne forensic psychologist.
He was the profiler of some of
Melbourne's most prominent criminals and gave evidence as an expert witness at
several notable criminal cases.
Watson-Munro was
one of the best-known and busiest people in his field.
Others, including a
former colleagues, however saw him as a "big-noter who hung around with the
wrong people."
In September 1999,
Watson-Munro, then 46 and of Hawthorn, was charged with using and possessing
cocaine between January 1, 1997, and September 12, 1999.
A street-smart
operator with a flair for self-publicity, he parlayed his unusual
double-barrelled name into a recognised label in the way some astute criminal
barristers do, establishing reputations that rival their talents.
He formed a
symbiotic relationship with several such advocates, who called him as an expert
witness for the defence in hundreds of cases.
In the 1990's,
Watson-Munro was quoted in 172 newspaper stories nationwide, and had been a
regular on radio and television.
He was seen as a man whose opinion is for hire
- and who became a fixture on the short list of "dial-a-quote'' experts
automatically called for comment by many in the media.
The cases
Watson-Munro had been involved with included those of child killer, Mr Cruel,
and Hoddle street gunman, Julian Knight.
In November 1988,
he was quoted blaming "bastardisation'' at Duntroon Military College for
contributing to his clients murderous shooting rampage.
He also counselled
four of the Hoddle St survivors.
In the early
1990's, Watson-Munro was a vital expert witness on the state of business tycoon,
Alan Bond's health.
In December 1993,
Watson-Munro flew across the continent to tell the magistrate that Bond was
anxious and depressed, had "spoken of suicide and lacked the mental ability
to run a corner store" - an opinion that prompted guffaws among Bond
watchers.
This testimony led
to Bond's trial on the Manet fraud charges being put off for six months and
almost led to Bond's bankruptcy examination being abandoned altogether.
Prominent criminal lawyer and friend of Watson-Munro, Andrew
Fraser, arrested on drugs charges shortly before Watson-Munro, was also on
Bond's team.
Watson-Munro had
sworn to a court that Mr Bond was depressed, fragile, vulnerable, suicidal and
anxious - and would be so stressed in the witness box he could break down.
In a January 2002
article in the Herald Sun and written by Derryn Hinch, the journalist recalled a
book he had read entitled "Going for broke - How Bond got away with
it", by
Paul Barry.
Hinch referred to Alan
Bond as the biggest and bravest, most brazen and clever corporate crook and
reminded the reader that in his youth, Bond was caught on premises with
housebreaking equipment.
What grabbed the
attention of Hinch was a 1994 photo portraying a "tragic Bondy, having
collapsed on the first day of his fraud trial in Perth, staggering from the
court in his raincoat with his eyes closed and face in a tormented grimace.
On
one side is lawyer Andrew
Fraser, later jailed for cocaine importation.
Clutching the other arm and looking concerned is Tim Watson-Munro.
Hinch concluded his
piece by writing "we don't know what Fraser
and Mr Watson Munro were on at the time Mr Bond was on the run."
By the age of 46,
Watson-Munro managed to make himself the best-known forensic psychologist in
Australia, not only by what he said in court but what he said outside it.
He also counselled
underworld figures including standover man, drug dealer and alleged murderer Alphonse
Gangitano - a client for 18 months before his execution-style slaying in
1998.
In 1995
Watson-Munro was covertly observed dining with
Gangitano,
and big time WA drug trafficker John
Kizon at a Melbourne restaurant.
Kizon was a criminal at the centre of West Australian inquiries involving corrupt
police activities, especially bribery.
There were also two well known underworld
stand over men at the lunch.
Watson-Munro gave
character references for
Gangitano who had pleaded guilty to 13 charges including threatening to kill a policeman,
weapons possession and inflicting serious injury.
In 1997, when
disgraced former Coles Myer executive Brian Quinn faced court, Watson-Munro gave
evidence that he suffered from "reactive depression''.
Ironically, at a
time when his own cocaine use was turning from social to habitual, he was
treating private school children for their drug problems - and happily milking
publicity from it - solemnly stating that some were spending
"fortunes" on amphetamines and cocaine.
On September 14,
1999, Watson-Munro was questioned by the drug squad as part of Operation
Regent.
Senior Constable Mick
Batten later told Melbourne
Magistrates Court that Watson-Munro had surrendered to police after a five-week
drug squad investigation.
Early that day, a
subdued Watson-Munro walked into the foyer of St Kilda Road CIB headquarters
with his lawyer, Brian Rolfe, quietly identified himself to the two officers at the reception desk and asked to go to the drug squad offices on the
12th floor.
Watson-Munro looked
ill. He was drawn, thin and jumpy.
He had chosen to turn himself in before the
police came knocking.
In the words of one detective, "he surrendered
because he knew the game was up''.
He was asked about 150 questions.
Watson-Munro was no
stranger at the crime complex, which is only a few blocks away from his office
near the corner of Commercial Road.
A self-promoted expert in all matters
criminal, one of his many hats had been to advise police on hostages and
negotiation.
Drug squad
detectives weren't surprised to see the man in the dark suit.
He was there by
appointment.
Two days before, they had arrested another prominent professional, Andrew
Fraser, over possession of cocaine, and warrants had already been sworn to
search Watson-Munro's office and house in Hawthorn.
Watson-Munro
answered every one of the questions put to him by police.
In just 40 minutes he
poured out the story of how a professional achiever had reduced his life to the
tawdry daily ritual of chasing a gram of cocaine to stick up his nose.
He had to
admit he had become just another junkie.
Senior Constable
Batten said Watson-Munro was identified through tapes of conversations
intercepted in a city office as part of the investigation.
He told the court
that Watson-Munro had first tried cocaine four years ago, but during the past 12
months came to use a gram of the drug each day.
Having been trapped
by the phone intercepts and bugs (at one point actually snorting cocaine),
Watson-Munro made a statement to police, in the hope that he would be treated
more leniently.
He also appeared to have alleged that
Fraser supplied him with cocaine.
If convicted,
Watson-Munro realised he could face a maximum jail term of five years.
On Tuesday
December 16, 1999, he went to Melbourne Magistrates Court to confess in public
what he had been forced to confess in private three months earlier.
Watson-Munro
admitted in court to a $2000-a-week cocaine addiction and claimed to have
suffered a major depressive illness.
The criminal psychologist decided to plead
guilty to one count of cocaine use and one count of possession.
His counsel, Mr
Terry Forrest, QC, told the court that Watson-Munro's
use of the drug had increased because of the depressive illness he suffered
after losing his first wife to cancer the previous year.
He had also lost a baby from
his second marriage.
Watson-Munro also
talked of the code he and
Fraser used when discussing drugs over the phone.
"I've got the boots and I'm
ready to play footy," was one such euphemism to put listeners off the
scent.
"I'm going to see a man who has lots of concrete blocks in his
car," was another.
When giving evidence
in the case of
Fraser,
a 'sad and crumpled' Watson-Munro for the prosecution was asked by
Fraser's
defence, Geoff Chettle whether he had evidence that Fraser sold drugs to him for
profit.
He said he did not.
He agreed that he had asked
Fraser to "procure" for him "as a friend".
"It's a bit like
going down to the shop and asking someone to pick up something for me while
you're there?", Chettle asked. "Yes," said Watson-Munro,
"that's a sound analogy."
Ms
Lillian Lieder, QC, who also represented Alphonse
Gangitano, gave character evidence for Watson-Munro,
with whom she has worked for more than 15 years.
"I have always found him
to be a man of the highest integrity," she said.
The magistrate, Mr
Bruce Cottrill , said a conviction would halt a "significant and very
important" career and Watson-Munro had already paid an "enormous
price" through his addiction that had cost him $2000 a week.
Mr Cottrill said he
had been impressed by character witnesses, and Watson-Munro's integrity was
"beyond reproach".
He fined him $1000 and placed him on a 12-month
good behaviour bond.
This decision
provoked uproar in the Melbourne legal fraternity.
An example of the anger some
people felt is posted below.
Tim
Watson-Munro - By Emanuel Goldberg January 1, 2001 from cyberjustice.com.au
What standards does the Psychologists Board have when one of it's high-profile
practitioners, Tim Watson-Munro, is allowed to practise after admitting using
cocaine for four years and having a cocaine habit?
Who in their right
mind would seek help from a person who has a $300 a day cocaine habit and has
recently been found guilty of professional misconduct by his own psychology
board?
In the past the word
"professional" was an obligation, not just a title accepted without
responsibility.
Tim Watson-Munro
received a $1000 fine and a good behaviour bond.
What sentence was inflicted on
his clients who were recipients of what he considered were "professional
assessments"?
What adverse effects
did his drug habit have on ability to make accurate assessments? How did this
affect his clients and their families?
The media went to
great lengths to report on his depression and inability to cope with life's
problems, almost to the point of expecting sympathy for his actions.
If such a
high-profile psychologist with all his contacts and lucrative income can't be
assisted by his own profession, when suffering from depression, what does this
say about this profession?
All of this makes me
depressed.
|